减少重复影像检查:腹部CT后72小时内住院与急诊腹部超声检查
研究在电子病历中设置最佳实践咨询(BPA),对72小时内已行腹部CT的成人住院和急诊患者提示避免腹部超声。BPA运行6个月共触发614次医嘱,16%(96例)被取消;对518例override中44%(227例)保留医嘱主要用于胆囊评估,病历回顾认为被取消的超声不会影响患者诊疗。
要点
- 腹部CT后72小时内再开腹部超声,BPA仅使16%医嘱取消,提示重复检查机会仍大
- 保留的超声医嘱多数用于胆囊评估(44%,227/518),病历回顾确认其有临床价值
- 被取消的超声经病历回顾确认未对患者诊疗造成影响
核心结论
- 近期已行腹部CT可能使住院和急诊患者无需再行腹部超声,尤其在医院获得性急性肾损伤情况下。
- BPA仅使16%的医嘱被取消,而病历回顾显示避免重复影像的机会远大于此。
研究设计与样本
- 质量改进项目:在电子病历中创建最佳实践咨询(BPA),对72小时内已行腹部CT的成人住院和急诊患者提示避免腹部超声。
- BPA整合入电子病历6个月后评估其触发频率及后续开单行为;对100例通过override开具的医嘱进行病历回顾以判断超声是否带来附加价值,并对所有超声被取消的患者进行病历回顾以确认省略超声未影响诊疗。
诊断标准与关键数值
- BPA触发条件:成人住院或急诊患者,且此前72小时内已行腹部CT。
- 前6个月共614例住院和急诊腹部超声医嘱触发BPA,其中96例(16%)被开具者取消,518例被override保留。
- 保留医嘱中多数用于评估胆囊(44%,227/518)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 对72小时内已行腹部CT的住院或急诊患者开具腹部超声时,BPA会提示避免重复检查。
- 开具者可选择override并注明可接受的继续检查理由;保留医嘱最常见的目的是评估胆囊。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: The aim of this project was to reduce abdominal ultrasound examinations in patients who had undergone abdominal CT within 72 hours previously.
METHODS: A best practice advisory (BPA) was created in the electronic medical record to advise against the use of abdominal ultrasound in adult inpatients and emergency department patients who had undergone abdominal CT within the preceding 72 hours. Acceptable acknowledgment reasons to proceed with the order were made available if providers chose to override. Frequency of BPA firing and subsequent ordering behavior were evaluated 6 months after integration of the BPA into the electronic medical record. Chart review was conducted for 100 patients whose orders were placed through an override of the alert to determine if the ultrasound study added value and for all patients whose ultrasound studies were canceled to confirm that patient care was not compromised by omitting the ultrasound study.
RESULTS: In the first 6 months, a total of 614 inpatient and emergency department abdominal ultrasound orders triggered the BPA. A total of 16% of orders (n = 96) were canceled by the provider after the BPA, reflecting 518 overrides. The majority of retained orders were to evaluate the gallbladder (44% [227 of 518]). Chart review confirmed utility for gallbladder imaging and that the canceled ultrasound examinations would not have contributed value to patients' care.
CONCLUSIONS: A recently performed abdominal CT scan may obviate the need for inpatient and emergency department abdominal ultrasound, particularly in the setting of hospital-acquired acute kidney injury. A BPA resulted in only 16% of orders' being canceled, whereas chart review revealed a much larger opportunity to avoid duplicative imaging.
引用
- Adenaw N, Wen J, Pahwa AK, et al. Decreasing Duplicative Imaging: Inpatient and Emergency Medicine Abdominal Ultrasound Within 72 Hours of Abdominal CT. J Am Coll Radiol. 2020. PMID: 32247697. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2020.03.010
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。