癌症多学科团队会议中放射学实践的国家审计
该国家审计评估影像科室对皇家学院(Royal College)癌症多学科团队会议(MDTM)标准的依从性,覆盖乳腺、结直肠和肺癌MDTM。145/191(76%)家医院响应,放射科全面参会率为52-65%,补充报告标注分期/治疗计划者为15-26%,44-77%的迟到病例未预先审阅影像即讨论。结论认为放射科医生无法全面达到皇家学院(Royal College)MDTM标准,转诊增加似乎是主要因素。
要点
- 放射科全面参与MDTM的比例为52-65%,补充报告标注分期/治疗计划者仅15-26%。
- 44-77%的迟到病例在未预先审阅影像的情况下被讨论。
- 13%的放射科医生工作计划中无MDTM活动时间,51%认为MDTM转诊增加带来负面影响。
核心结论
- 放射科医生无法全面达到皇家学院(Royal College)关于在影像上提供并记录专科意见的MDTM标准。
- MDTM转诊增加似乎是主要因素,需要区分哪些复杂病例受益于MDTM讨论、哪些可通过治疗路径管理。
- 更好地利用MDTM前会议/表单和信息技术可能进一步帮助放射科医生为MDTM提供一致的高质量贡献。
研究设计与样本
- 该国家审计由通用部分和亚专科部分组成,针对乳腺、结直肠和肺癌MDTM完成。
- 审计响应为皇家学院(Royal College)国家审计中最高,145/191(76%)家医院响应。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 放射科全面MDTM参会率为52-65%。
- 补充报告标注分期/治疗计划的发生率为15-26%。
- 迟到病例在未预先审阅影像的情况下被讨论的频率为44-77%。
- 与原始影像报告不一致之处在MDTM上被充分记录的比例为92-94%,并在差异会议上汇报的比例为70-81%。
- 从MDTM参与中学习并同行反馈的沟通比例为76-84%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 13%的放射科医生工作计划中无MDTM活动时间,51%认为MDTM转诊增加带来负面影响。
- 改善MDTM工作量的辅助措施实施不佳,如治疗路径/算法(乳腺/结直肠54%)和表单(43-50%)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
AIM: A national audit reviewing compliance of imaging departments with the Royal College of Radiologist (RCR) standards for cancer multidisciplinary team meetings (MDTMs).
MATERIALS AND METHODS: The audit consisted of a generic and subspecialty component completed for breast, colorectal, and lung cancer MDTMs.
RESULTS: The study achieved the highest response from a RCR national audit with 145/191 (76%) hospitals responding. Compliance with the RCR standards was suboptimal, particularly relating to MDTM attendance, documentation, and reviewing MDTM imaging. Comprehensive radiology MDTM attendance occurred in 52-65%, a supplementary report denoting staging/treatment plans happened in 15-26%, and late additions were discussed frequently without prior review of imaging (44-77%). Contributing factors maybe 13% of radiologists had no programmed activity for MDTMs in their job plan and a perceived negative impact of increasing MDTM referrals (51%). Adjuncts to improve MDTM workload, such as treatment pathways/algorithms (breast/colorectal 54%) and pro-forma (43-50%), were poorly implemented. Discrepancies with the original imaging report highlighted at MDTMs were well documented (92-94%) and frequently presented at discrepancy meetings (70-81%). Learning from involvement in MDTM was well communicated with 76-84% providing peer feedback.
CONCLUSIONS: Radiologists are unable to comprehensively attain the RCR MDTM standards on providing and documenting a specialist opinion on the imaging. Increasing referrals to the MDTM appears the predominant factor and differentiating complex cases that benefit from MDTM discussion from those that can be managed via treatment pathways is required. Improved utilisation of pre-MDTMs/pro-forma and information technology in MDTMs may further aid radiologists to provide consistent high-quality contribution towards MDTMs.
引用
- Balasubramaniam R, Drinkwater K, Howlett DC, et al. A national audit of radiology practice in cancer multidisciplinary team meetings. Clin Radiol. 2020. PMID: 32327228. doi:10.1016/j.crad.2020.03.031
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。