各培训层级放射科医生采用不同灰度显示方式通过CT血管造影检测急性大血管闭塞性卒中的敏感度均高
该随机交叉对照实验纳入18名不同经验放射科医生,用标准与灰度反转方式判读CT血管造影检测急性大血管闭塞(ELVO)。各层级医生敏感度和特异度均>0.94,神经放射科医生判读更快(平均47秒,非神经放射科医生59秒、住院医师74秒),灰度反转在诊断性能、检测时间、总判读时间和信心上均无显著差异。
要点
- 各层级放射科医生CTA检测ELVO的敏感度和特异度均>0.94。
- 神经放射科医生平均47秒检出ELVO,快于非神经放射科医生59秒和住院医师74秒。
- 灰度反转与标准显示在诊断性能(p=0.30)、检测时间(p=.45)等方面无显著差异。
核心结论
- 各培训层级放射科医生用CTA检测ELVO的诊断性能均高,灰度反转未提供显著检测优势。
研究设计与样本
- 随机、平衡对照实验设计,18名不同经验放射科医生对同一批患者图像分别以标准显示和灰度反转判读,确诊阳性与阴性ELVO病例按平衡设计随机排序;采用广义混合模型分析。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 各层级放射科医生检测ELVO的敏感度和特异度均>.94。
- 灰度反转与标准显示比较:诊断性能p=0.30,检测时间p=.45,总体判读时间p=.97,信心p=.20。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 神经放射科医生平均47秒检出ELVO,非神经放射科医生59秒,住院医师74秒。
- 住院医师主观信心低于主治医师。
- 灰度反转与标准显示在诊断性能、检测时间、总体判读时间和信心方面均无显著差异。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: CT angiography (CTA) is essential in acute stroke to detect emergent large vessel occlusions (ELVO) and must be interpreted by radiologists with and without subspecialized training. Additionally, grayscale inversion has been suggested to improve diagnostic accuracy in other radiology applications. This study examines diagnostic performance in ELVO detection between neuroradiologists, non-neuroradiologists, and radiology residents using standard and grayscale inversion viewing methods.
METHODS: A random, counterbalanced experimental design was used, where 18 radiologists with varying experiences interpreted the same patient images with and without grayscale inversion. Confirmed positive and negative ELVO cases were randomly ordered using a balanced design. Sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values as well as confidence, subjective assessment of image quality, time to ELVO detection, and overall interpretation time were examined between grayscale inversion (on/off) by experience level using generalized mixed modeling assuming a binary, negative binomial, and binomial distributions, respectively.
RESULTS: All groups of radiologists had high sensitivity and specificity for ELVO detection (all > .94). Neuroradiologists were faster than non-neuroradiologists and residents in interpretation time, with a mean of 47 s to detect ELVO, as compared with 59 and 74 s, respectively. Residents were subjectively less confident than attending physicians. With respect to grayscale inversion, no differences were observed between groups with grayscale inversion vs. standard viewing for diagnostic performance (p = 0.30), detection time (p = .45), overall interpretation time (p = .97), and confidence (p = .20).
CONCLUSIONS: Diagnostic performance in ELVO detection with CTA was high across all levels of radiologist training level. Grayscale inversion offered no significant detection advantage.
KEY POINTS: • Stroke is an acute vascular syndrome that requires acute vascular imaging. • Proximal large vessel occlusions can be identified quickly and accurately by radiologists across all training levels. • Grayscale inversion demonstrated minimal detectable benefit in the detection of proximal large vessel occlusions.
引用
- Boyd CA, Jayaraman MV, Baird GL, et al. Detection of emergent large vessel occlusion stroke with CT angiography is high across all levels of radiology training and grayscale viewing methods. Eur Radiol. 2020. PMID: 32232790. doi:10.1007/s00330-020-06814-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。