手部管状骨真的是内生软骨瘤最常见部位吗
两项回顾性研究:第一部分统计两家大型教学医院10年手部外伤X线片,内生软骨瘤发生率为0.07%(84/116354);第二部分回顾157例MRI上<4 cm的肱骨近端、股骨远端和胫骨近端内生软骨瘤,仅17%长度<2 cm的病变在同期X线片上可见,2–2.9 cm和3–3.9 cm病变可见率分别升至58%和77%。结论认为手部不应再被视为内生软骨瘤最常见部位。
要点
- 手部外伤X线片内生软骨瘤发生率仅0.07%(84/116354),低于肩膝关节MRI偶发内生软骨瘤约2.5%的报道。
- MRI上<2 cm的内生软骨瘤仅17%在同期X线片可见,2–2.9 cm和3–3.9 cm病变可见率分别为58%和77%。
- X线对肱骨近端和膝关节周围较大骨内小病变相对不敏感,手部不应再被视为内生软骨瘤最常见部位。
核心结论
- 现有研究报道约2.5%的常规肩关节和膝关节MRI扫描可见偶发内生软骨瘤,该数字是手部外伤X线片系列发生率的35倍,提示手部不应再被视为内生软骨瘤最常见部位。
- 原因是与MRI相比,X线对肱骨近端和膝关节周围等较大骨内小病变的检测相对不敏感。
研究设计与样本
- 两部分回顾性研究:第一部分复习两家大型教学医院10年间的手部X线片以确定手部内生软骨瘤发生率。
- 第二部分复习MRI上长度<4 cm的肱骨近端、股骨远端和胫骨近端内生软骨瘤系列,对照相应X线片判断病变是否可见。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 第一部分:116354张外伤X线片中发现84例内生软骨瘤,发生率为0.07%。
- 第二部分:157例MRI上<4 cm的内生软骨瘤患者中,长度<2 cm的病变仅17%在同期X线片可见。
- 长度2–2.9 cm和3–3.9 cm的病变在X线片上的可见率分别增至58%和77%。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
AIM: To investigate whether the long-held view that the hand is the commonest site for an enchondroma is actually correct in light of more sensitive imaging techniques that are able to demonstrate small enchondromas at other skeletal sites.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: A two-part retrospective study was undertaken. Part 1 comprised a review of the hand radiographs obtained in two major teaching hospitals over a 10-year period to establish the incidence of enchondroma in the hand. Part 2 was a review of a series of enchondromas of the proximal humerus, distal femur, and proximal tibia <4 cm in length on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to see which cases were visible or not on corresponding radiographs.
RESULTS: Part 1: 84 enchondromas were identified on 116,354 trauma radiographs to give an incidence of 0.07%. Part 2: 157 patients with an enchondroma on MRI <4 cm were reviewed. Only 17% of lesions <2 cm in length were visible on the contemporaneous radiographs. In lesions that were 2-2.9 and 3-3.9 cm the percentage visible on the radiographs increased to 58 and 77%, respectively.
CONCLUSION: It is well recognised from existing studies that incidental enchondromas can be seen in approximately 2.5% of routine shoulder and knee MRI scans. This figure is 35 times higher than the incidence found in the series of hand trauma radiographs. This infers that the hand should no longer be considered as the commonest site for an enchondroma. This is because radiographs are relatively insensitive to the detection of small lesions in larger bones, such as the proximal humerus and around the knee, when compared with MRI.
引用
- Davies AM, Shah A, Shah R, et al. Are the tubular bones of the hand really the commonest site for an enchondroma? Clin Radiol. 2020. PMID: 32183998. doi:10.1016/j.crad.2020.02.004
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。