产科肛门括约肌损伤的临床分级与四维经会阴超声分级的一致性如何
该回顾性研究纳入2012至2018年间产后近期OASI修补后就诊于会阴门诊的215例患者,比较临床分级与四维经会阴超声新算法分级的一致性。临床与超声分级完全一致者占50%(加权κ=0.398),45%相差一个等级,6%相差两个等级;33%疑似临床过度诊断,17%疑似诊断不足。肛失禁和/或便急症状与超声分级无显著关联(P=0.052)。
要点
- 临床与超声OASI分级完全一致仅50%,加权κ=0.398,一致性一般。
- 33%疑似临床过度诊断,17%疑似诊断不足,报告时需注意分级差异。
- 诊断医师资历不影响临床与超声分级的一致性(专科医师κ=0.44,高年资住院医师κ=0.43,低年资住院医师κ=0.34)。
核心结论
- 临床与经会阴超声OASI分级的一致性为一般(加权κ=0.398)。
- 本研究中临床过度诊断可能较常见,但诊断不足仍可见于相当一部分少数患者。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入2012至2018年间会阴门诊产后近期OASI初次修补后患者,共215例完整数据集。
- 所有患者接受标准化访谈(含St Mark's肛失禁测试)和四维经会阴超声,超声容积数据后处理对全部其他数据设盲。
- 采用断层超声成像获取8个切片,评估中央6个切片;临床分级依据皇家学院(Royal College)妇产科医师指南。
关键影像表现/征象
- 断层超声成像中央6个切片中,切片出现扭曲、变薄或缺陷评为异常。
- 24例(11%)影像显示肛门括约肌正常。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 超声OASI分级算法:肛门外括约肌异常<4/6切片为3a级;肛门外括约肌异常≥4/6切片为3b级;肛门外括约肌和肛门内括约肌均异常≥4/6切片为3c/4级。
- 临床分级:3a级87例,3b级80例,3c级29例,4级19例。
- 临床与超声分级完全一致107例(50%),加权κ=0.398;相差一个等级96例(45%),加权κ=0.74;相差两个等级12例(6%)。
- 疑似临床过度诊断72例(33%),疑似诊断不足36例(17%)。
- 诊断医师资历与一致性:专科医师κ=0.44,高年资住院医师κ=0.43,低年资住院医师κ=0.34,差异无统计学意义。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 临床与超声OASI分级一致性一般,阅片报告时需注意临床过度诊断(33%)和诊断不足(17%)的可能。
- 超声评估采用中央6个切片,按肛门外括约肌和肛门内括约肌异常切片数进行3a、3b、3c/4级分级。
局限性
- 本研究为回顾性研究,存在缺失数据,260例中45例(17%)因数据缺失或重复OASI被排除。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the agreement between grading of obstetric anal sphincter injuries (OASI) on translabial ultrasound (TLUS), using a newly developed algorithm, and grading on postpartum examination. A secondary aim was to assess the correlation between tear severity, as defined on ultrasound, and symptoms of anal incontinence and/or fecal urgency.
METHODS: This was a retrospective study of patients seen at a perineal clinic between 2012 and 2018, after recent primary repair of OASI. All patients underwent a standardized interview including the St Mark's anal incontinence test and four-dimensional TLUS. Post-processing of ultrasound volume data was performed blinded to all other data. Using tomographic ultrasound imaging, a set of eight slices was obtained, and the central six slices were evaluated for sphincter abnormalities. Slices with distortion, thinning or defects were rated as abnormal. The following algorithm was used to grade OASI: a Grade-3a tear was diagnosed if the external anal sphincter (EAS) was abnormal in < 4/6 slices; a Grade-3b tear was diagnosed if the EAS was abnormal in ≥ 4/6 slices; and a Grade-3c/4 tear was diagnosed if both the EAS and internal anal sphincter were abnormal in ≥ 4/6 slices. Clinical grading of OASI was determined according to the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists guidelines. Agreement between clinical and TLUS diagnosis of OASI was evaluated using weighted κ.
RESULTS: Of the 260 women seen during the study period, 45 (17%) were excluded owing to missing data or a repeat OASI, leaving 215 complete datasets for analysis. The average follow-up interval was 2.4 months (range, 1-11 months) after OASI and the mean age of the women was 29 years (range, 17-42 years). One hundred and seventy-five (81%) women were vaginally primiparous. OASI was graded clinically as Grade 3a in 87 women, Grade 3b in 80, Grade 3c in 29 and Grade 4 in 19. On imaging, full agreement between clinical and TLUS grading was noted in 107 (50%) women, with a weighted κ of 0.398. In 96 (45%) women, there was disagreement by one category, with a weighted κ of 0.74 and in 12 (6%) there was disagreement by two categories. Twenty-four (11%) women were found to have a normal anal sphincter on imaging. Overall, potential clinical over-diagnosis was noted in 72 (33%) women and potential under-diagnosis in 36 (17%). The seniority of the diagnosing obstetrician did not significantly alter agreement between clinical and sonographic OASI grading (κ 0.44, 0.43, and 0.34, for specialists and senior and junior residents, respectively). The association between symptoms of anal incontinence and/or fecal urgency and TLUS grading did not reach significance (P = 0.052).
CONCLUSIONS: Clinical and TLUS-based grading of OASI showed fair agreement. Clinical over-diagnosis may be increasingly common in our population, although under-diagnosis may still occur in a significant minority. Copyright © 2020 ISUOG. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
引用
- Gillor M, Shek KL, Dietz HP, et al. How comparable is clinical grading of obstetric anal sphincter injury with that determined by four-dimensional translabial ultrasound? Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2020. PMID: 32149422. doi:10.1002/uog.22011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。