非心电门控低剂量胸部CT上的冠状动脉钙化严重程度分级:全国肺癌筛查登记中的多观察者研究
本研究从韩国肺癌筛查(K-LUCAS)项目中回顾性纳入256名受试者,由4名心胸放射科医生独立采用视觉评估、基于动脉的分级、基于节段累及的分级和基于节段的分级四种方法评估非心电门控低剂量胸部CT上的冠状动脉钙化严重程度。结果显示视觉评估的观察者间一致性为中等(Fleiss kappa 0.451),其余三种方法为基本一致(Fleiss kappa 0.673-0.704);基于动脉的分级具有基本一致的观察者间一致性和可接受的平均评估时间(17.6秒)。
要点
- 基于动脉的分级观察者间一致性基本一致(Fleiss kappa 0.704),平均评估时间17.6秒。
- 视觉评估观察者间一致性中等(Fleiss kappa 0.451),但平均评估时间最短(14.3秒)。
- 基于节段的分级平均评估时间最长(34.2秒),观察者间一致性基本一致(Fleiss kappa 0.673)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 观察者间一致性:视觉评估Fleiss kappa 0.451(中等);基于动脉的分级、基于节段累及的分级和基于节段的分级Fleiss kappa 0.673-0.704(基本一致)。
- 同一观察者内四种分级方法间的一致性:3名观察者Fleiss kappa 0.610-0.705(基本一致),1名观察者Fleiss kappa 0.578(中等)。
- 平均评估时间:视觉评估14.3 ± 11.8秒;基于动脉的分级17.6 ± 22.3秒;基于节段累及的分级19.2 ± 6.8秒;基于节段的分级34.2 ± 37.4秒;p < 0.01。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 在非心电门控低剂量胸部CT上评估冠状动脉钙化严重程度时,基于动脉的分级可能适用,因其观察者间一致性基本一致且平均评估时间可接受。
- 视觉评估虽然平均评估时间最短,但观察者间变异性高。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To identify the optimal method for evaluation of coronary artery calcium (CAC) severity on non-electrocardiogram-gated low-dose chest computed tomography (LDCT) in a nationwide lung cancer screening registry.
METHODS: A total of 256 subjects were retrospectively enrolled from participants of the Korean Lung Cancer Screening (K-LUCAS) project (an LDCT lung cancer screening registry for high-risk individuals). Four board-certified cardiothoracic radiologists independently assessed CAC severity using four different scoring methods (visual assessment, artery-based grading, segment-involvement grading, and segment-based grading) and classified severity for each case using all four methods as none, mild, moderate, or severe. Agreements between the four observers for CAC category classification and between the four different scoring methods for the same observer were assessed by Fleiss kappa statistics. Evaluation time for CAC grading was compared between observers and between grading methods.
RESULTS: Interobserver agreement was moderate for visual assessment (Fleiss kappa 0.451) and substantial for the other three methods (Fleiss kappa 0.673-0.704). Agreement between the four grading methods for the same observer was substantial for three observers (Fleiss kappa 0.610-0.705) and moderate for one (Fleiss kappa 0.578). Mean evaluation time differed significantly between methods (visual assessment, 14.3 ± 11.8 s; artery-based grading, 17.6 ± 22.3 s, segment-involvement grading, 19.2 ± 6.8 s; segment-based grading, 34.2 ± 37.4 s; p < 0.01).
CONCLUSION: Artery-based grading could be appropriate with substantial interobserver agreement and an acceptable mean evaluation time.
KEY POINTS: • CAC severity grading methods on LDCT show moderate to substantial agreements between grading methods and observers. • Artery-based grading could be appropriate with substantial interobserver agreement and a mean evaluation time of 17.6 s. • Visual assessment is disadvantaged by high interobserver variability despite having the shortest evaluation time.
引用
- Suh YJ, Lee JW, Shin SY, et al. Coronary artery calcium severity grading on non-ECG-gated low-dose chest computed tomography: a multiple-observer study in a nationwide lung cancer screening registry. Eur Radiol. 2020. PMID: 32144461. doi:10.1007/s00330-020-06707-x
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。