肺癌评估中非诊断性CT引导肺活检的影像-病理相关性
本研究回顾性分析2013年7月至2017年6月间1525例肺活检中243例非诊断性活检,其中98例用于肺癌评估,排除17例随访不足后纳入81例。最终42%(34/81)为恶性,阴性预测值为58%;组织肺炎病理恶性率最低(20%),非典型细胞最高(50%)。Brock和Herder模型AUC均为0.52,无预测价值;两位胸部放射科医生评分AUC分别为0.85和0.77,评分1-2分时阴性预测值达90%和95%。结论认为胸部放射科医生进行影像-病理一致性审阅可筛选可能受益于重复活检的患者。
要点
- 非诊断性肺活检中42%(34/81)最终为恶性,阴性预测值仅58%。
- 胸部放射科医生盲法评分(1-5分)AUC达0.85和0.77,评分1-2分时阴性预测值90%和95%。
- Brock和Herder模型在此高度选择队列中无预测价值,AUC均为0.52。
核心结论
- 胸部放射科医生对非诊断性肺活检进行影像-病理一致性审阅,可筛选可能受益于重复活检的患者。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,2013年7月至2017年6月共1525例肺活检,其中243例非诊断性,98例用于肺癌评估,排除17例随访不足后纳入81例;由两位胸部放射科医生独立盲法评分(1分可能良性至5分可能恶性),并计算Brock和Herder模型风险;最终诊断由病理结果或病灶消退/稳定至少2年确定良性。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 非诊断性活检最终恶性率42%(34/81),阴性预测值58%;组织肺炎病理恶性率最低(2/10=20%),非典型细胞最高(5/10=50%,p=0.51);Brock和Herder模型AUC均为0.52;放射科医生评分AUC分别为0.85和0.77;评分1和2分视为良性时阴性预测值分别为90%和95%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 对非诊断性肺活检,可由胸部放射科医生结合影像与病理结果进行一致性评分(1-5分),评分1-2分提示良性可能性大(阴性预测值90%-95%),评分较高者可能受益于重复活检。
局限性
- 本研究为回顾性研究。
- 排除17例随访不足病例后仅纳入81例。
- 组织肺炎与非典型细胞恶性率比较p=0.51。
- Brock和Herder模型在此高度选择队列中无预测价值(AUC均为0.52)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE. For nondiagnostic CT-guided lung biopsies, we tested whether radiologicpathologic correlation could identify patients who may benefit from repeat biopsy. MATERIALS AND METHODS. In this retrospective study, 1525 lung biopsies were performed between July 2013 and June 2017, 243 of which were nondiagnostic. Of these 243 lung biopsies, 98 were performed to evaluate for lung malignancy; 17 were excluded because of insufficient follow-up, leaving a total of 81 cases. The Brock and Herder models were used to calculate risk; in addition, cases were independently blindly reviewed by two thoracic radiologists who assigned a score from 1 (probably benign) to 5 (probably malignant). The final diagnosis was established by pathology results or benignancy was established if the lesion resolved or remained stable for at least 2 years. RESULTS. Of the 81 nondiagnostic lung biopsies, initial pathology results included 33 cases of inflammation, 28 cases of normal lung tissue or insufficient sample, 10 cases of organizing pneumonia, and 10 cases of atypical cells. 42% (34/81) of cases were eventually determined to be malignant (negative predictive value [NPV] of 58%). Pathology results of organizing pneumonia had the lowest rate of malignancy (2/10 = 20%), and pathology results of atypical cells had the highest rate of malignancy (5/10 = 50%, p = 0.51). Within this highly selected cohort, the Brock and Herder models were not predictive of malignancy, with areas under the ROC curve (AUCs) of 0.52 and 0.52, respectively. Evaluation by thoracic radiologists yielded AUCs of 0.85 and 0.77. When radiologist-assigned scores of 1 and 2 were considered as benign, the NPV was 90% and 95%. CONCLUSION. Review of nondiagnostic lung biopsies for radiologic-pathologic concordance by thoracic radiologists can triage patients who may benefit from repeat biopsy.
引用
- Ma Y, Byrne SC, Gange C, et al. Radiologic-Pathologic Correlation for Nondiagnostic CT-Guided Lung Biopsies Performed for the Evaluation of Lung Cancer. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2020. PMID: 32160056. doi:10.2214/AJR.19.22244
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。