亚兹德省常见计算机断层扫描检查相关的辐射剂量与曝露诱发死亡风险
该调查评估了亚兹德省6家机构5种最常见CT检查的患者有效剂量及相应风险,用ImpactDose软件估算有效剂量,并结合BEIR VII模型与ICRP 103亚洲人群数据计算曝露诱发死亡风险。腹部-盆腔中位有效剂量最高(5.19 mSv),各检查间最大与最小有效剂量比值平均达90倍;女性胸部高分辨率CT风险最高,20岁患者每2096次检查可致1例曝露诱发死亡。除鼻窦外各检查剂量相对较低,但同一检查的患者剂量差异很大,提示需进一步优化。
要点
- 腹部-盆腔CT中位有效剂量最高,为5.19 mSv,鼻窦CT最低,为0.47 mSv。
- 各检查间最大与最小有效剂量比值平均达90倍,同一检查的患者剂量差异也很大。
- 女性胸部高分辨率CT风险最高,20岁患者每2096次检查可致1例曝露诱发死亡。
核心结论
- 除鼻窦外所有检查的估算有效剂量相对较低,但患者剂量差异很大,提示需进一步开展优化流程。
- 20岁女性约2000次腹部-盆腔CT检查可致1例辐射诱发癌症死亡,大规模应用可能造成严重健康问题,可建议采用诊断参考水平(DRL)等方法来降低CT检查的集体剂量。
研究设计与样本
- 该调查于2017年9月起从6家机构收集5种最常见CT检查的数据。
- 采用ImpactDose软件估算每位患者的有效剂量。
- 通过耦合BEIR VII模型与ICRP 103亚洲人群数据计算曝露诱发死亡风险(REID)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 5种最常见检查的中位有效剂量按降序为:腹部-盆腔5.19 mSv、常规胸部3.30 mSv、胸部高分辨率CT 3.00 mSv、脑部0.76 mSv、鼻窦0.47 mSv。
- 所有检查平均的最大与最小有效剂量比值为90倍。
- 最高相关风险见于女性高分辨率CT扫描,估计为20岁患者每2096次检查相关1例曝露诱发死亡。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: This survey was conducted to evaluate the radiation dose delivered to the patients through different CT procedures along with its corresponding risks in Yazd province.
METHOD: Data for the five most common procedures were collected from six institutions from September 2017. The effective dose for each patient was estimated by ImpactDose software. The risk of exposure-induced death (REID) was calculated by coupling the BEIR VII model and ICRP 103 data for the Asian population.
RESULTS: The median effective doses for the five most common procedures, in descending order, were as follows: 5.19 mSv for abdomen-pelvis, 3.30 mSv for routine chest, 3.00 mSv for chest HRCT, 0.76 mSv for Brain and 0.47 mSv for sinus. Averaged over all the procedures, the ratio of maximum to minimum of effective dose was 90-fold. The highest associated risk was tied to high-resolution CT scans for women which was estimated to be 1 exposure-induced death related to 2096 scans performed on a 20-year old patient.
CONCLUSION: The estimated effective doses for all the procedures except sinus were comparably low, however, the variations among patient doses, even for a given procedure, were substantially high, indicating that further optimization processes need to be undertaken. Moreover, it was estimated that approximately 2000 scans of abdomen-pelvis performed on 20 year-old women could result in 1 radiation-induced cancer death, which in large scales may cause drastic health issues. In this regard, several approaches, one of which is the implementation of DRLs, can be suggested to reduce the collective dose from CT scans.
引用
- Masjedi H, Omidi R, Zamani H, et al. Radiation dose and risk of exposure-induced death associated with common computed tomography procedures in Yazd Province. Eur J Radiol. 2020. PMID: 32200290. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2020.108932
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。