放射科医生驱动的变更医嘱请求对门诊CT和MRI检查的影响
本研究分析了2017年4月11日至2018年1月3日期间在某三级医疗中心由方案制定放射科医生发起变更医嘱请求的门诊CT和MRI申请,评估变更请求的比例、提供者接受度、辐射暴露降低和成本。结果显示MRI变更请求率高于CT,提供者对CT和MRI变更请求的批准率均为82%,变更常导致更低成本的检查,CT中51%的批准变更降低了辐射暴露。
要点
- 门诊CT和MRI申请中被放射科医生判定为不正确的比例为2.9%至5%。
- 提供者对CT和MRI变更请求的批准率均为82%。
- CT批准变更中51%降低了辐射暴露。
诊断标准与关键数值
- MRI变更请求率为5.2%(1283/24553),CT为2.9%(1585/54757),P < .001。
- 提供者对变更请求的批准率CT为82%(1299/1585),MRI为82%(1052/1283)。
- 因对比剂使用不当驱动的变更请求CT为76%(992/1299),MRI为65%(688/1052),P < .001。
- CT中最常见的变更类型为「无静脉对比剂和有静脉对比剂医嘱改为仅含对比剂」占39%(505/1299),MRI中为「有和无静脉对比剂医嘱改为仅无对比剂」占26%(274/1052),P < .001。
- CT批准变更中51%(661/1299)降低了辐射暴露;批准变更常导致更低成本的检查(CT 67% [799/1198],MRI 48% [411/863])。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To assess impact of electronic medical record-embedded radiologist-driven change-order request on outpatient CT and MRI examinations.
METHODS: Outpatient CT and MRI requests where an order change was requested by the protocoling radiologist in our tertiary care center, from April 11, 2017, to January 3, 2018, were analyzed. Percentage and categorization of requested order change, provider acceptance of requested change, patient and provider demographics, estimated radiation exposure reduction, and cost were analyzed. P < .05 was used for statistical significance.
RESULTS: In 79,310 outpatient studies in which radiologists determined protocol, change-order requests were higher for MRI (5.2%, 1,283 of 24,553) compared with CT (2.9%, 1,585 of 54,757; P < .001). Provider approval of requested change was equivalent for CT (82%, 1,299 of 1,585) and MRI (82%, 1,052 of 1,283). Change requests driven by improper contrast media utilization were most common and different between CT (76%, 992 of 1,299) and MRI (65%, 688 of 1,052; P < .001). Changing without and with intravenous contrast orders to with contrast only was most common for CT (39%, 505 of 1,299) and with and without intravenous contrast to without contrast only was most common for MRI (26%, 274 of 1,052; P < .001). Of approved changes in CT, 51% (661 of 1,299) resulted in lower radiation exposure. Approved changes frequently resulted in less costly examinations (CT 67% [799 of 1,198], MRI 48% [411 of 863]).
CONCLUSION: Outpatient CT and MRI orders are deemed incorrect in 2.9% to 5% of cases. Radiologist-driven change-order request for CT and MRI are well accepted by ordering providers and decrease radiation exposure associated with imaging.
引用
- Pourjabbar S, Cavallo JJ, Arango J, et al. Impact of Radiologist-Driven Change-Order Requests on Outpatient CT and MRI Examinations. J Am Coll Radiol. 2020. PMID: 31954708. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2019.12.017
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。