文献速递儿科影像泌尿生殖妇产影像US

卵巢扭转:开发用于诊断的机器学习算法

Ovarian torsion: developing a machine-learned algorithm for diagnosis.
PubMed 文献 · Pediatr Radiol · 2020-01-22

本研究基于11年间一家四级儿科医院收治的99例1岁以上经手术确诊的卵巢扭转患儿及331例非扭转对照,提取超声特征并输入监督式机器学习系统构建决策算法。最佳决策树组合卵巢内血流、周边卵泡、双侧卵巢体积及囊肿或肿块,AUC达0.96±0.07,敏感度95±14%、特异度92±2%。

要点

  • 单用任一超声特征诊断卵巢扭转效能有限,卵巢内血流消失的AUC为0.82±0.14。
  • 联合卵巢内血流、周边卵泡、双侧卵巢体积及囊肿或肿块的最佳决策树AUC为0.96±0.07。
  • 临床实用决策树诊断卵巢扭转的敏感度为95±14%、特异度为92±2%。

关键影像表现/征象

  • 共识别119例扭转确诊病例和331例非扭转病例,其中1岁以下女童影像差异显著而被排除,最终纳入99例1岁以上患儿进行分析。
  • 在99例中,所有变量在扭转确诊组与非扭转组之间差异均有统计学意义,P值<0.005。
  • 最佳决策树需了解卵巢内血流存在与否、周边卵泡、双侧卵巢体积以及囊肿或肿块的存在情况,其AUC为0.96±0.07。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 单用卵巢内侧化识别扭转的AUC为0.76±0.16。
  • 单用周边卵泡识别扭转的AUC为0.66±0.14。
  • 单用多普勒血流消失识别扭转的AUC为0.82±0.14。
  • 最佳决策树组合变量识别扭转的AUC为0.96±0.07。
  • 临床实用决策树检测扭转的敏感度为95±14%、特异度为92±2%。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 作者采用机器学习算法整合卵巢内血流、周边卵泡、双侧卵巢体积及囊肿或肿块等超声特征来辅助放射科医生诊断卵巢扭转。
  • 作者指出依赖单一超声特征诊断卵巢扭转效能有限,而联合多变量的临床实用决策树可达到敏感度95±14%和特异度92±2%。

局限性

  • 1岁以下女童因影像差异显著被排除分析,最终分析仅纳入99例1岁以上患儿。
  • 使用任何单一变量识别扭转仅提供有限的检测性能。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND: Ovarian torsion is a common concern in girls presenting to emergency care with pelvic or abdominal pain. The diagnosis is challenging to make accurately and quickly, relying on a combination of physical exam, history and radiologic evaluation. Failure to establish the diagnosis in a timely fashion can result in irreversible ovarian ischemia with implications for future fertility. Ultrasound is the mainstay of evaluation for ovarian torsion in the pediatric population. However, even with a high index of suspicion, imaging features are not pathognomonic.

OBJECTIVE: We sought to develop an algorithm to aid radiologists in diagnosing ovarian torsion using machine learning from sonographic features and to evaluate the frequency of each sonographic element.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: All pediatric patients treated for ovarian torsion at a quaternary pediatric hospital over an 11-year period were identified by both an internal radiology database and hospital-based International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems (ICD) code review. Inclusion criteria were surgical confirmation of ovarian torsion and available imaging. Patients were excluded if the diagnosis could not be confirmed, no imaging was available for review, the ovary was not identified by imaging, or torsion involved other adnexal structures but spared the ovary. Data collection included: patient age; laterality of torsion; bilateral ovarian volumes; torsed ovarian position, i.e. whether medialized with respect to the mid-uterine line; presence or absence of Doppler signal within the torsed ovary; visualization of peripheral follicles; and presence of a mass or cyst, and free peritoneal fluid. Subsequently, we evaluated a non-torsed control cohort from April 2015 to May 2016. This cohort consisted of sequential girls and young adults presenting to the emergency department with abdominopelvic symptoms concerning for ovarian torsion but who were ultimately diagnosed otherwise. These features were then fed into supervised machine learning systems to identify and develop viable decision algorithms. We divided data into training and validation sets and assessed algorithm performance using sub-sets of the validation set.

RESULTS: We identified 119 torsion-confirmed cases and 331 torsion-absent cases. Of the torsion-confirmed cases, significant imaging differences were evident for girls younger than 1 year; these girls were then excluded from analysis, and 99 pediatric patients older than 1 year were included in our study. Among these 99, all variables demonstrated statistically significant differences between the torsion-confirmed and torsion-absent groups with P-values <0.005. Using any single variable to identify torsion provided only modest detection performance, with areas under the curve (AUC) for medialization, peripheral follicles, and absence of Doppler flow of 0.76±0.16, 0.66±0.14 and 0.82±0.14, respectively. The best decision tree using a combination of variables yielded an AUC of 0.96±0.07 and required knowledge of the presence of intra-ovarian flow, peripheral follicles, the volume of both ovaries, and the presence of cysts or masses.

CONCLUSION: Based on the largest series of pediatric ovarian torsion in the literature to date, we quantified sonographic features and used machine learning to create an algorithm to identify the presence of ovarian torsion - an algorithm that performs better than simple approaches relying on single features. Although complex combinations using multiple-interaction models provide slightly better performance, a clinically pragmatic decision tree can be employed to detect torsion, providing sensitivity levels of 95±14% and specificity of 92±2%.

来源:Pediatr Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Otjen JP, Stanescu AL, Alessio AM, et al. Ovarian torsion: developing a machine-learned algorithm for diagnosis. Pediatr Radiol. 2020. PMID: 31970456. doi:10.1007/s00247-019-04601-3

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。