纵向MRI环境中平均上颈髓面积实施的考量:方法、评分者间信度与MRI质量控制
本研究基于T1加权脑MRI,评估健康参与者平均上颈髓面积的技术变异与重扫描变异。结果显示,非畸变校正MRI、半自动分割和单一评分者可使脊髓测量技术变异降低;满足MR图像质量标准时,组平均上颈髓面积的重扫描变异在±4.4%以内。
要点
- 非畸变校正与畸变校正MPRAGE所得平均上颈髓面积数值相近,但配对t检验显示两者不可比(t=11.0,P<.001)。
- 自动分割法计算的平均上颈髓面积变异更高;评分者间分析显示同一参与者扫描的测量不可比(t=4.5,P<.001)。
- 满足MR图像质量标准时,组平均上颈髓面积的重扫描变异在±4.4%以内。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 非畸变校正与畸变校正MPRAGE衍生的平均上颈髓面积相似,但配对t检验显示不可比(t=11.0,P<.001)。
- 自动分割法计算的平均上颈髓面积变异更高。
- 评分者间分析显示同一参与者扫描的测量不可比(t=4.5,P<.001)。
- 非畸变校正平均上颈髓面积测量在真实世界数据中表现稳健(t=-1.04,P=.31)。
- 满足MR图像质量标准时,组平均上颈髓面积的重扫描变异在±4.4%以内。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 采用非畸变校正MRI、半自动分割方法和单一评分者有助于降低脊髓测量的技术变异。
- 运动伪影、头颈部位置和/或金属植入物是变异的主要来源,阅片和测量时需关注这些因素对图像质量的影响。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Spinal cord atrophy is commonly measured from cerebral MRIs, including the upper cervical cord. However, rescan intraparticipant measures have not been investigated in healthy cohorts. This study investigated technical and rescan variability in the mean upper cervical cord area calculated from T1-weighted cerebral MRIs.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: In this retrospective study, 8 healthy participants were scanned and rescanned with non-distortion- and distortion-corrected MPRAGE sequences (11-50 sessions in 6-8 months), and 50 participants were scanned once with distortion-corrected MPRAGE sequences in the Day2day daily variability study. From another real-world observational cohort, we collected non-distortion-corrected MPRAGE scans from 27 healthy participants (annually for 2-4 years) and cross-sectionally from 77 participants. Statistical analyses included coefficient of variation, smallest real difference, intraclass correlation coefficient, Bland-Altman limits of agreement, and paired t tests.
RESULTS: Distortion- versus non-distortion-corrected MPRAGE-derived mean upper cervical cord areas were similar; however, a paired t test showed incomparability (t = 11.0, P = <.001). Higher variability was found in the mean upper cervical cord areas calculated from an automatic segmentation method. Interrater analysis yielded incomparable measures in the same participant scans (t = 4.5, P = <.001). Non-distortion-corrected mean upper cervical cord area measures were shown to be robust in real-world data (t = -1.04, P = .31). The main sources of variability were found to be artifacts from movement, head/neck positioning, and/or metal implants.
CONCLUSIONS: Technical variability in cord measures decreased using non-distortion-corrected MRIs, a semiautomatic segmentation approach, and 1 rater. Rescan variability was within ±4.4% for group mean upper cervical cord area when MR imaging quality criteria were met.
引用
- Chien C, Juenger V, Scheel M, et al. Considerations for Mean Upper Cervical Cord Area Implementation in a Longitudinal MRI Setting: Methods, Interrater Reliability, and MRI Quality Control. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2020. PMID: 31974079. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A6394
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。