超声图像处理中应用动态循环和结构标志物可提高足部及小腿肌肉评估的可靠性并减少误差
研究纳入12名健康志愿者,比较静态图像与动态循环测量足部及小腿肌肉的可靠性。结果显示动态循环使操作者内和操作者间组内相关系数提高0.5%至4%,新手操作者内测量标准误和一致性界限分别降低45%至73%和24%至51%,操作者间标准误和一致性界限分别降低42%至53%和27%至40%。
要点
- 动态循环较静态图像可提高足部及小腿肌肉测量的操作者内和操作者间可靠性。
- 动态循环可降低新手操作者内测量标准误和一致性界限,使其与有经验者使用静态图像时相当。
- 胫骨前肌在各可靠性指标上未见实质性变化。
核心结论
- 利用内部骨性标志物和动态循环改进的方案可提高下肢肌肉尺寸变化研究的可靠性。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入12名健康志愿者,包括8名男性和4名女性,平均年龄±标准差为23.5±1.9岁。
- 使用内部标志物(舟骨结节)和外部标志物(膝关节线30%和50%处的小腿外侧长度)。
- 两名操作者分别采集并测量所选足部及小腿肌肉的静态图像和动态循环图像。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 操作者内和操作者间组内相关系数范围为0.946至0.998。
- 动态循环使操作者内和操作者间组内相关系数提高0.5%至4%。
- 动态循环使新手操作者内测量标准误降低45%至73%,一致性界限降低24%至51%。
- 操作者间测量标准误降低42%至53%,一致性界限降低27%至40%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Foot and leg muscle strength and size are crucial to proper function. It is important to assess these characteristics reliably. Our primary objective was to compare the measurement of still images to cine loops. The secondary purpose was to determine interoperator and intraoperator reliability between operators of different experience levels using video clips and internal and external landmarks.
METHODS: Twelve healthy volunteers participated in our study. Internal (navicular tuberosity) and external (lateral leg length at 30% and 50% from the knee joint line) landmarks were used. Two operators each captured and later measured still and cine loop images of selected foot and leg muscles.
RESULTS: The 12 participants included 8 male and 4 female volunteers (mean age ± SD, 23.5 ± 1.9 years). Good to excellent intraoperator and interoperator reliability was seen (intraclass correlation coefficient range of 0.946-0.998). The use of cine loops improved the intraclass correlation coefficients for both intraoperator and interoperator reliability (0.5%-4% increases). The use of cine loops decreased the intraoperator standard error of the measurement and limits of agreement of the novice operator (decreases of 45%-73% and 24%-51%, respectively), and these became comparable to those of experienced operators using still images. The interoperator standard errors of the measurement dropped by 42% to 53%, whereas the limits of agreement dropped by 27% to 40%. No substantial changes were noted in the tibialis anterior across reliability metrics.
CONCLUSIONS: Improved protocols that take advantage of using internal bony landmarks and cine loops during both the image-gathering and measurement processes improve the reliability of research examining muscle size changes in the lower leg or foot associated with muscle changes due to exercise, injury, disuse, or disease.
引用
- Johnson AW, Stoneman P, McClung MS, et al. Use of Cine Loops and Structural Landmarks in Ultrasound Image Processing Improves Reliability and Reduces Error in the Assessment of Foot and Leg Muscles. J Ultrasound Med. 2019. PMID: 31837060. doi:10.1002/jum.15192
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。