文献速递神经骨肌MR

神经与肌肉骨骼MRI的低阅读量和高阅读量阅片者:实现放射学亚专科化

Low-Volume and High-Volume Readers of Neurological and Musculoskeletal MRI: Achieving Subspecialization in Radiology.
PubMed 文献 · J Am Coll Radiol · 2019-12-26

该研究基于2015年Medicare数据,用三种方法(wRVU占比、绝对阅读量、两者结合)区分神经(Neuro)和肌肉骨骼(MSK)MRI的高阅读量与低阅读量放射科医生,并计算低阅读量医生解读的检查比例。结果显示大量Neuro或MSK MRI由低阅读量医生解读,且不同阈值下比例差异大;哪种方法及阈值与阅片质量最相关尚不清楚。

要点

  • 低阅读量医生解读了相当比例的Neuro和MSK MRI,方法3下分别为38%和57%。
  • 采用50% wRVU阈值时,低阅读量医生解读的Neuro MRI达70%–77%,MSK MRI达80%–90%。
  • 区分低阅读量医生的方法及阈值与阅片质量的相关性尚不明确。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 方法1阈值20%:Neuro MRI的33%和MSK MRI的50%由Neuro或MSK MRI wRVU占比低于20%的医生解读。
  • 方法2阈值:Neuro MRI的22%和MSK MRI的37%由阅读量低于「平均全职放射科医生」平均数的医生解读,该平均医生Neuro或MSK MRI的wRVU占比约20%。
  • 方法3:Neuro MRI的38%和MSK MRI的57%由「低阅读量」医生解读。
  • 方法1、2、3采用50% wRVU阈值时,低阅读量医生解读的Neuro MRI分别为70%、58%、77%,MSK MRI分别为86%、80%、90%。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 尚不清楚哪种区分低阅读量医生的方法结合哪个阈值最能反映高绩效或低绩效医生。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVE: Differentiate high- versus low-volume radiologists who interpret neurological (Neuro) MRI or musculoskeletal (MSK) MRI and measure the proportion of Neuro and MSK MRIs read by low-volume radiologists.

METHODS: We queried the 2015 Medicare Physician and Other Supplier Public Use File for radiologists who submitted claims for Neuro or MSK MRIs. Radiologists were classified as high-volume versus low-volume based on their work relative value units (wRVUs) focus or volume of studies interpreted using three different methodologies: Method 1, percentage of wRVUs in Neuro or MSK MRI; Method 2, absolute number of Neuro or MSK MRIs interpreted; and Method 3, both percentage and absolute number. Multiple thresholds with each methodology were tested, and the percentage of Neuro or MSK MRIs interpreted by low-volume radiologists was calculated for each threshold.

RESULTS: With Method 1, 33% of Neuro MRI and 50% of MSK MRI studies were interpreted by a radiologist whose wRVUs in Neuro or MSK MRI were less than 20% (Method 1). With Method 2, 22% of Neuro MRIs and 37% of MSK MRIs were interpreted by radiologists who read fewer than the mean number of Neuro or MSK MRIs interpreted by an "average full-time radiologist" whose wRVUs in Neuro or MSK MRI were approximately 20%. With Method 3, 38% of Neuro MRIs and 57% of MSK MRIs were interpreted by "low-volume" radiologists. If instead a 50% wRVU threshold is used for Methods One, Two, and Three, then 70%, 58%, and 77% of Neuro MRIs and 86%, 80%, and 90% of MSK MRIs are read by low-volume radiologists.

DISCUSSION: A large number of radiologists read a low volume of Neuro or MSK MRIs; these low-volume Neuro or MSK MRI radiologists read a substantial portion of Neuro or MSK MRIs. It is unknown which of the methods for distinguishing low-volume radiologists, combined with which threshold, may best correlate with high-performing or low-performing radiologists.

来源:J Am Coll Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Trinh B, Calabrese E, Vu T, et al. Low-Volume and High-Volume Readers of Neurological and Musculoskeletal MRI: Achieving Subspecialization in Radiology. J Am Coll Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31883842. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2019.10.006

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。