经皮放射学胃造瘘置管术前CT与腹部X线检查的效用评估
回顾性分析126例经皮放射学胃造瘘(PRG)置管请求,所有患者均有术前腹部CT,其中110例同时有腹部X线。CT判断适合PRG的窗口比例为83%,X线为73%;CT拒绝者中9%成功行经皮内镜下胃造瘘,CT敏感度98%;X线判断有满意解剖者97%成功置管,敏感度77%;CT与X线一致率73%。结论认为术前CT对成功且无并发症的PRG具有高度预测价值,腹部X线虽也能预测成功但准确性较低,限制了其作为术前检查的效用。
要点
- 术前CT判断有足够窗口者占83%,X线为73%,CT与X线一致率73%。
- CT拒绝行PRG者中仅9%成功行经皮内镜下胃造瘘,CT敏感度达98%。
- X线判断有满意解剖者97%成功置管,但X线敏感度仅77%。
核心结论
- 术前CT解读对成功且无并发症的PRG具有高度预测价值。
- 腹部X线也能预测成功PRG,但准确性较低,限制了其作为术前检查的效用。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性综述,在三级医疗放射科进行,纳入126例PRG置管请求,所有患者均有术前腹部CT,其中110例同时有术前腹部X线。
- 记录CT是否被解读为具有适合PRG的足够窗口,并回顾性评估X线是否存在适合PRG的满意解剖,同时回顾置管结局。
诊断标准与关键数值
- CT判断有足够PRG窗口者占83%,X线判断有满意解剖者占73%。
- CT拒绝行PRG者中9%成功行经皮内镜下胃造瘘,CT敏感度为98%。
- X线判断有满意解剖者中97%成功行PRG;X线判断无窗口者中66%经CT判断有窗口,其中尝试置管者94%成功,X线敏感度为77%。
- CT与X线一致率为73%。
- 尝试置管者中94%成功行PRG,轻微并发症发生率为7.4%。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To evaluate the utility of pre-procedural CT and abdominal radiography before percutaneous radiologic gastrostomy tube placement.
METHODS: A retrospective review of gastrostomy tube placements was conducted at a tertiary care radiology department. During the studied period, all percutaneous radiologic G-tube placements (PRG) at the institution required a pre-procedural abdominal CT. Whether the CT was interpreted to have an adequate window for PRG was recorded. The same patients with pre-procedural abdominal radiographs were also identified and retrospectively reviewed for the presence of satisfactory anatomy for PRG. Outcomes of tube placements were reviewed.
RESULTS: 126 PRG requests were identified, all with abdominal CTs. 110 also had an abdominal radiograph. An adequate window for PRG was present in 83% of patients by CT and 73% by radiography. Of patients in whom it was attempted, 94% underwent successful PRG with a 7.4% minor complication rate. Of those refused for PRG based on CT, 9% had successful percutaneous endoscopic G-tube placement, resulting in a sensitivity of 98%. 97% of patients with satisfactory anatomy by radiograph underwent successful PRG. Of those with no window, 66% had a window by CT, and 94% in whom it was attempted had successful PRG placement. This resulted in a sensitivity of 77% for radiography. Concordance between CT and radiography was 73%.
CONCLUSIONS: Pre-procedural CT interpretation is highly predictive of successful and uncomplicated PRG. Abdominal radiography also predicts successful PRG, but with a lower accuracy, limiting its utility as a pre-procedural exam.
引用
- Gutjahr CJ, Iverson EP, Walker ST, et al. Utility of pre-procedural CT and abdominal radiography before percutaneous radiologic gastrostomy placement. Abdom Radiol (NY). 2020. PMID: 31797024. doi:10.1007/s00261-019-02352-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。