晚期碘增强心脏计算机断层扫描检测心肌瘢痕:临床实践中经验的影响
研究以晚期钆增强MRI为参考,评估晚期碘增强心脏CT对不同经验阅片者、瘢痕模式和对比噪声比的诊断效能。结果显示经验丰富者诊断准确度和敏感度更高,特异度均优异;漏诊瘢痕多为非缺血性模式、低瘢痕负荷且对比噪声比较低。
要点
- 经验丰富阅片者逐患者准确度95%、敏感度93%,经验较少者为88%和83%。
- 特异度不受经验影响,逐患者100%、逐节段99%。
- 漏诊瘢痕多为非缺血性模式、瘢痕负荷低于6%且对比噪声比较低。
关键影像表现/征象
- 晚期碘增强心脏CT上瘢痕负荷与MRI的相关性,经验丰富阅片者ρ=0.954,经验较少者ρ=0.797,p<0.001。
- 经验丰富阅片者漏诊2例患者和141个节段中的21个;经验较少者漏诊5例患者和141个节段中的53个。
- 漏诊瘢痕为非缺血性模式,瘢痕负荷<6%,对比噪声比低于缺血性瘢痕(2.33 vs 3.54,p=0.005)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 逐患者分析:经验丰富阅片者准确度95%、敏感度93%,经验较少者准确度88%、敏感度83%。
- 逐节段分析:经验丰富阅片者准确度96%、敏感度85%,经验较少者准确度92%、敏感度62%。
- 特异度:逐患者100%、逐节段99%,与阅片者经验无关。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 阅片时应注意,经验较少者对小非缺血性瘢痕的敏感度较低(逐节段62% vs 85%)。
- 瘢痕负荷低于6%且对比噪声比较低时,漏诊风险可能增加。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Cardiac CT with late iodine enhancement (LIE-CT) may characterize the scarred myocardium, but the role of readers' experience and scar pattern on LIE-CT diagnostic performance is unknown. Aim was to assess the diagnostic performance of LIE-CT according to readers' experience, scar pattern and contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) using late gadolinium enhancement MRI (LGE-MRI) as reference.
METHODS: LIE-CT and LGE-MRI images of 40 consecutive patients were analyzed. Two readers with different experience (8 and 2 years) independently analyzed LIE-CT images defining the presence/absence of scar and scar CNR, segmental involvement, transmural pattern and scar etiology. The same parameters were extracted from LGE-MRI by two expert readers in consensus, blinded to the LIE-CT results.
RESULTS: Scars were identified at LGE-MRI in 29/40 patients and 141/680 segments. Scar burden at LIE-CT versus LGE-MRI correlated better for the most experienced reader than for the least experienced one (ρ = 0.954 and ρ = 0.797, p < 0.001). The most experienced reader missed scars in 2 patients and in 21/141 segments; the least experienced in 5 patients and 53/141 segments. The most experienced reader showed higher accuracy and sensitivity compared to the least experienced in per-patient (accuracy: 95% vs. 88%; sensitivity: 93% vs. 83%) and per-segment analysis (accuracy: 96% vs. 92%; sensitivity: 85% vs. 62%). Specificity was excellent (100% per-patient, 99% per-segment,) regardless of readers' experience. Missed scars had non-ischemic pattern, low scar burden (< 6%) and lower CNR compared to ischemic scars (2.33 vs. 3.54, p = 0.005).
CONCLUSION: LIE-CT represents an alternative to LGE-MRI, although the impact of readers' experience on sensitivity for small non-ischemic scars should be considered.
引用
- Palmisano A, Vignale D, Benedetti G, et al. Late iodine enhancement cardiac computed tomography for detection of myocardial scars: impact of experience in the clinical practice. Radiol Med. 2019. PMID: 31784926. doi:10.1007/s11547-019-01108-7
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。