指南与共识心血管技术与安全PET

基于胜任力的医学教育:心脏影像培训指南是否正确?

Competency-Based Medical Education: Do the Cardiac Imaging Training Guidelines Have it Right?
指南 / 共识 · JACC Cardiovasc Imaging · 2019-01-01

研究连续纳入24名学员独立判读的9668例心肌灌注显像(MPI),与专家判读对照,每50例计算一次kappa一致性。学员与专家的一致性随病例量增加但速率不同;以专家间一致性低2个标准差为胜任阈值,平均学员在800例总MPI或400例异常MPI后超过该阈值。作者认为基于胜任力的医学教育在核心脏病学可行,现行指南可能不足以确保胜任力,支持增加MPI病例量并转向目标一致性阈值。

要点

  • 学员与专家判读MPI的一致性随病例量增加而提高,但不同学员提高速率不同。
  • 以专家间一致性低2个标准差为胜任阈值,平均学员在800例总MPI或400例异常MPI后达标。
  • 作者认为现行培训病例量指南可能不足以确保胜任力,支持增加MPI病例量。

核心结论

  • 在核心脏病学中采用基于胜任力的医学教育似乎是可行的。
  • 结果提示现行指南可能不足以确保胜任力,并支持需要增加MPI病例量。
  • 基于胜任力的医学教育原则提示学员可能以不同速率达到胜任力,结果提示应从基于病例量的学习转向目标一致性阈值。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究为连续纳入MPI研究,由学员独立判读、专家判读同一批研究进行对照。
  • 共24名学员在37个月内判读9668例MPI研究。
  • 使用 summed score 和左心室缺血百分比(%LV ischemia)量化,每50例测量学员与专家间kappa一致性。
  • 计算所有MPI和异常MPI病例的一致性;胜任阈值设为专家间一致性低2个标准差。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 胜任阈值设定为专家间观察者一致性低2个标准差。
  • 平均学员在800例总MPI研究和400例异常MPI研究后,在 summed stress score 和 %LV ischemia 两项指标上均超过胜任阈值。
  • 学员与专家的一致性随MPI病例量增加而提高,但不同学员提高速率不同,超过胜任阈值所需病例量不同。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 作者认为基于胜任力的医学教育在核心脏病学似乎可行。
  • 作者认为现行指南可能不足以确保胜任力,并支持需要增加MPI病例量。
  • 作者建议从基于病例量的学习转向目标一致性阈值,学员可能以不同速率达到胜任力。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVES: This study sought to: 1) determine if the current training volume guidelines are reasonable for attaining competence for interpreting myocardial perfusion imaging (MPI); and if not, 2) identify potential thresholds for training volumes and competence.

BACKGROUND: There is a growing desire to adopt competency-based medical education (CBME). As such, the implementation of CBME will require new and novel methods of defining, measuring, and assessing clinical competence. The potential use of CBME in cardiac imaging has not been well studied.

METHODS: Consecutive MPI studies were interpreted independently by trainees, and expert readers reviewed the same studies. Studies were quantified using summed scores and % left ventricular (LV) ischemia and the kappa agreement between trainee and expert were measured every 50 cases. Agreement for all MPI and abnormal MPI cases was calculated.

RESULTS: A total of 24 trainees interpreted 9,668 MPI studies over 37 months. Agreement between trainees and expert readers increased with MPI case volumes but at different rates. The threshold for competence was set at 2 SDs below expert interobserver agreement. The average trainee surpassed this threshold for both summed stress score and %LV ischemia after 800 studies and after 400 abnormal MPI studies. Trainees learned at different rates and surpassed the competence threshold after different case volumes.

CONCLUSIONS: The use of CBME within nuclear cardiology appears to be feasible. Our results suggest that current guidelines may be insufficient to ensure competence and would support the need to increase the MPI case volumes. The use of CBME principles would suggest that trainees may achieve competence at different rates and our results suggest a shift in focus from volume-based learning toward target agreement thresholds.

来源:JACC Cardiovasc Imaging,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Chow BJW, Alenazy A, Small G, et al. Competency-Based Medical Education: Do the Cardiac Imaging Training Guidelines Have it Right? JACC Cardiovasc Imaging. 2019. PMID: 31806181. doi:10.1016/j.jcmg.2019.09.021

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。