两种骨龄评估方法对沙特阿拉伯儿童的适用性
研究评估Greulich & Pyle(G&P)与Tanner & Whitehouse(TW3)两种骨龄评估方法对沙特阿拉伯儿童的适用性,采用两名观察者独立手工评分及BoneXpert软件评估420张手部创伤X线片。男性中G&P与TW3手工评估的骨龄与生活年龄均有统计学显著差异,女性中无显著差异;男性中BoneXpert与手工评分在TW3上一致,在G&P上不一致。
要点
- 沙特阿拉伯女性中手工及BoneXpert的G&P与TW3骨龄评估均无需修改即可应用
- 沙特阿拉伯男性中仅BoneXpert的TW3骨龄评估可无顾虑应用
- 男性G&P手工与BoneXpert评分差异有统计学意义,TW3两者一致
核心结论
- 手工及BoneXpert的G&P与TW3骨龄评估可无需修改应用于沙特阿拉伯女性
- 仅BoneXpert衍生的TW3骨龄可无顾虑应用于沙特阿拉伯男性
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入420张沙特阿拉伯人手部创伤X线片(男性220例,左手329张,年龄范围1-18岁),摄片时间为2012年1月至2016年9月
- 骨龄先后由两名观察者独立手工评分,随后由单一观察者使用BoneXpert软件评估,方法为G&P与TW3
- 采用配对样本t检验比较平均骨龄与平均生活年龄差异及手工与BoneXpert评分差异,使用SPSS v.25进行统计分析
诊断标准与关键数值
- 男性G&P手工评估骨龄与生活年龄平均差异-0.36±1岁(p<0.01),TW3平均差异-0.22±0.9岁(p=0.03)
- 女性G&P平均差异0.13±1.2岁,TW3平均差异0.08±1.1岁,均无统计学显著差异
- 男性中手工与BoneXpert评分在TW3上一致,在G&P上平均差异-0.27±0.5岁(p<0.01)
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
AIM: To assess the applicability of the Greulich & Pyle (G&P) and Tanner & Whitehouse (TW3) methods to children from Saudi Arabia using both subjective (manual) rating and BoneXpert software.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Bone age (BA) was assessed using the G&P and TW3 methods, firstly by independent manual rating of two observers, followed by a single observer using the BoneXpert software program. In total, 420 hand trauma radiographs for Saudi Arabians (220 males, 329 left, age range 1-18 years) performed in the period January 2012 to September 2016 were assessed. Paired sample t test was used to compare the difference between mean BA and mean chronological age (CA) and to compare the difference between manual and BoneXpert ratings. Statistical analysis was undertaken using SPSS v.25.
RESULTS: A statistically significant difference was found between BA and CA in males when using the G&P (mean difference -0.36±1 years, p<0.01) and TW3 (mean difference -0.22±0.9 years, p=0.03) methods, but not in females for either G&P (mean difference 0.13±1.2 years) or TW3 (mean difference 0.08±1.1 years). In males, BoneXpert results conformed to the manual ratings for TW3, but not for G&P, for which the mean difference between manual and BoneXpert ratings was -0.27±0.5 years (p<0.01).
DISCUSSION: The present results indicate that manual and BoneXpert-derived G&P and TW3 bone age assessment can be applied with no modification to Saudi Arabian females; however, only TW3 BoneXpert-derived BA can be applied without caution to Saudi Arabian males.
引用
- Alshamrani K, Hewitt A, Offiah AC, et al. Applicability of two bone age assessment methods to children from Saudi Arabia. Clin Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31706569. doi:10.1016/j.crad.2019.08.029
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。