瑞士成人CT国家诊断参考水平的更新及2010年以来辐射剂量降低的评估
该研究利用剂量管理软件收集2014至2017年间14家放射机构共50台CT扫描仪的成人CT剂量数据,按15个主协议计算第75百分位CTDIvol和DLP作为更新版国家诊断参考水平,并与2010年版比较。结果显示更新后DRL总体呈降低趋势,CTDIvol平均相对变化为-30%(0至-47%),DLP为-22%(+20%至-40%),其中颈椎方案DLP降幅最大(-40%),胸部方案-37%、排除肺栓塞方案-33%、颈部方案-32%、颈动脉血管造影方案-28%。结论认为更新版国家DRL显著低于2010年值,体现了技术进展和放射学界降低CT辐射暴露的努力。
要点
- 更新版瑞士成人CT国家DRL较2010年版显著降低,CTDIvol平均相对变化-30%(0至-47%),DLP平均-22%(+20%至-40%)。
- DLP降幅最大的方案为颈椎(-40%)、胸部(-37%)、排除肺栓塞(-33%)、颈部(-32%)和颈动脉血管造影(-28%)。
- 头部和腹部-盆腔方案的DRL相对变化较小,分别为-11%和-17%。
核心结论
- 更新版瑞士成人CT国家诊断参考水平显著低于2010年版,表明技术进展和放射学界降低CT辐射暴露的努力。
研究设计与样本
- 研究于2014至2017年间通过本地安装的剂量管理软件收集14家放射机构共50台CT扫描仪的CT剂量数据,数据清洗后共纳入220269例CT检查,按15个定义的主协议分配。
- 每个主协议的DRL按每台CT扫描仪的中位CTDIvol和DLP值分布的第75百分位计算。
诊断标准与关键数值
- CTDIvol的DRL平均相对变化为-30%(范围0至-47%),DLP的DRL平均相对变化为-22%(范围+20%至-40%),均与2010年版DRL比较。
- 各方案DLP的DRL相对变化:颈椎-40%,胸部-37%,排除肺栓塞-33%,颈部-32%,颈动脉血管造影-28%,头部-11%,腹部-盆腔-17%。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To update the national diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) for adult CT in Switzerland using dose management software and to compare them to the previous Swiss DRLs from 2010.
METHODS: CT dose data from 14 radiological institutes with a total of 50 CT scanners were collected with locally installed dose management software between 2014 and 2017. Data were assigned to 15 defined master protocols. Data cleaning steps were developed and adjusted individually for each participating institute and protocol. The DRLs for each master protocol were calculated as the 75th percentile of the distribution of the median volume computed tomography dose index (CTDIvol) and dose-length product (DLP) values per CT scanner.
RESULTS: In total, 220,269 CT exams were available after data cleaning. Updated DRLs showed a clear trend towards lower doses compared with previous DRLs. The average relative change in the DRLs for CTDIvol was - 30% (0 to - 47%) and - 22% for DLP (+ 20 to - 40%). The largest relative decrease in the DRL for DLP was observed for the cervical spine protocol (- 40%), the two chest protocols (chest, - 37%; and exclusion of pulmonary embolism, - 33%), and the two neck protocols (neck, - 32%; and carotid angiography, - 28%). The DRLs for other protocols, for example the head and the abdomen-pelvis protocol, showed smaller relative changes (- 11% and - 17%).
CONCLUSIONS: The updated national DRLs are substantially lower than the previous values from 2010, demonstrating technological progress and the efforts of the radiological community to lower CT radiation exposure.
KEY POINTS: • Dose management software allows the establishment of DRLs based on big data. • Updated Swiss DRLs for adult CT are substantially lower compared with those from 2010. • Swiss DRLs are low compared with other national DRLs.
引用
- Aberle C, Ryckx N, Treier R, et al. Update of national diagnostic reference levels for adult CT in Switzerland and assessment of radiation dose reduction since 2010. Eur Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31748858. doi:10.1007/s00330-019-06485-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。