双能CT鉴别颅内出血小病灶与钙化
本研究回顾性分析单中心急诊科2014年12月至2016年4月连续无增强头部双能CT,以参考标准CT或MRI为金标准,评估双能CT虚拟去钙图与钙图阈值鉴别颅内出血小病灶与钙化的诊断效能,并比较双能CT与模拟单能CT的读者诊断准确率与信心。
要点
- 虚拟去钙图阈值44 HU、钙图阈值7 HU,测试集诊断准确率分别为88%和95%。
- 双能CT使两位读者诊断准确率从90%和93%均提升至100%。
- 双能CT使读者诊断信心(「确定」分类)从71%和46%分别提升至90%和85%。
核心结论
- 双能CT在鉴别颅内出血小病灶与钙化方面表现出高诊断效能,并提高了疑似出血初始评估中的诊断准确率和信心。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入单中心急诊科2014年12月至2016年4月连续无增强头部双能CT的137例患者(65岁±17;70名男性)共146个高密度颅内病灶,以参考标准对比CT或MRI确定金标准,病灶分为开发集(n=105)和测试集(n=41),两名读者在不知最终诊断的情况下评估诊断效能与信心。
关键影像表现/征象
- 高密度颅内病灶在双能CT上通过虚拟去钙图和钙图进行定量分析以鉴别出血与钙化。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 开发集得出的候选阈值为虚拟去钙图44 HU、钙图7 HU,测试集诊断准确率分别为88%(36/41病灶;95%CI:78%,98%)和95%(39/41病灶;95%CI:88%,100%)。
- 双能CT使读者诊断准确率从读者1的90%(37/41病灶;95%CI:81%,99%)和读者2的93%(38/41病灶;95%CI:85%,100%)提升至两位读者均为100%(41/41病灶;95%CI:100%,100%)。
- 诊断信心(评为「确定」的分类)读者1从71%(29/41病灶;95%CI:57%,85%)提升至90%(37/41病灶;95%CI:81%,99%)(P = .019),读者2从46%(19/41病灶;95%CI:31%,62%)提升至85%(35/41病灶;95%CI:75%,96%)(P = .0001)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 对疑似颅内出血小病灶,可参考虚拟去钙图44 HU和钙图7 HU阈值辅助鉴别出血与钙化。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Background Diagnostic uncertainty in CT of possible intracranial hemorrhage requires short-interval follow-up imaging, resulting in reduced efficiency of care and higher costs. Purpose To quantify the diagnostic performance of dual-energy CT versus simulated single-energy CT in the differentiation of small foci of intracranial hemorrhage from calcium. Materials and Methods Images from consecutive unenhanced dual-energy CT of the head in patients from a single emergency department obtained from December 2014 to April 2016 were reviewed retrospectively for hyperattenuating intracranial foci. Ground truth was established from reference standard comparison CT or MRI. Foci were divided into development and test sets. Development set foci regions of interest were used to derive candidate CT attenuation thresholds for virtual noncalcium (VNCa) and calcium images. Test set foci were used for threshold validation, and diagnostic performance and confidence were evaluated for two readers blinded to final diagnosis. Statistical comparisons were made with exact binomial tests or repeated-measures analysis of variance. Results The study included 137 patients (65 years ± 17; 70 men) with 146 foci. Foci were divided into a development set (n = 105) and a test set (n = 41). Quantitative analysis of the development set produced candidate thresholds of 44 HU for VNCa images and 7 HU for calcium-only images, yielding diagnostic accuracies for the test set of 88% (36 of 41 foci; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 78%, 98%) and 95% (39 of 41 foci; 95% CI: 88%, 100%), respectively. Dual-energy CT improved reader accuracy from 90% (reader 1, 37 of 41 foci; 95% CI: 81%, 99%) and 93% (reader 2, 38 of 41 foci; 95% CI: 85%, 100%) to 100% (both readers, 41 of 41 foci; 95% CI: 100%, 100%). Diagnostic confidence (classifications rated as "certain") increased from 71% (29 of 41 foci; 95% CI: 57%, 85%) to 90% (37 of 41 foci; 95% CI: 81%, 99%) for reader 1 (P = .019) and from 46% (19 of 41 foci; 95% CI: 31%, 62%) to 85% (35 of 41 foci; 95% CI: 75%, 96%) for reader 2 (P = .0001). Conclusion Dual-energy CT showed high diagnostic performance in the differentiation of small foci of intracranial hemorrhage from calcium and improved diagnostic accuracy and confidence in the initial evaluation of suspected hemorrhage. © RSNA, 2019 See also the editorial by Kotsenas in this issue.
引用
- Wiggins WF, Potter CA, Sodickson AD, et al. Dual-Energy CT to Differentiate Small Foci of Intracranial Hemorrhage from Calcium. Radiology. 2019. PMID: 31687919. doi:10.1148/radiol.2019190792
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。