两种用于分娩前一周以上估算胎儿体重的新模型:一项MRI研究
研究纳入153例单胎妊娠,在MRI检查后15-21天内分娩,随机分为测试组102例和验证组51例,建立基于胎儿体积及体积联合MRI至分娩间隔的两种新模型,并在验证组与Baker模型比较。两种新模型平均百分比误差均为3.9%,误差<10%的比例分别为92.2%和90.2%;Baker模型误差约为新模型的两倍。结论认为Baker模型在分娩前一周以上估算胎儿体重准确性差,新模型显著改善。
要点
- MRI估算胎儿体重超过分娩前一周时,应纳入MRI至分娩间隔,而非仅用体积。
- 新模型验证组平均百分比误差为3.9%,Baker模型误差约为其两倍。
- 体积联合MRI至分娩间隔的模型误差<5%的比例为72.5%,高于单体积模型的64.7%。
核心结论
- Baker模型在分娩前一周以上估算胎儿体重的准确性差,两种新模型显著提高了准确性。
- 联合胎儿体积与MRI至分娩间隔可更准确地确定估算胎儿体重。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入153例单胎妊娠,均为足月正常活产新生儿,且于MRI检查后15-21天内分娩,具备胎儿体积生物测量数据。
- 所有胎儿随机分为测试组102例和验证组51例。
- 采用回归分析确定单一体积或体积联合MRI至分娩间隔对估算胎儿体重的决定作用。
- 在验证组中评估两种新模型与Baker等原有主要模型的准确性。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 两种新模型的平均百分比误差分别为3.9%和3.9%,平均百分比误差<10%的妊娠比例分别为92.2%和90.2%。
- 联合体积与MRI至分娩间隔的模型平均百分比误差<5%的妊娠比例为72.5%,单体积模型为64.7%。
- 联合体积与MRI至分娩间隔的模型估算胎儿体重与出生体重的一致性相对更高。
- Baker模型的误差几乎为两种新模型的两倍。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 在分娩前一周以上使用MRI估算胎儿体重时,可考虑将MRI至分娩间隔纳入模型以提高准确性。
- 原文结论提示联合胎儿体积与MRI至分娩间隔可更准确地确定估算胎儿体重。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To develop and evaluate new formulas to determine the magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)-based estimated foetal weight (EFW) more than a week before delivery.
METHODS: The study included 153 women with singleton pregnancies who gave birth to live, normal neonates within 15-21 days of the MRI examination for whom foetal body volume biometry data were available at term. All foetuses were randomly divided into a testing group (102) and a validation group (51). Regression analysis was used to determine the single volume or the combination of volume and MRI-to-delivery interval that determined the EFW. The accuracy of the two new models and the primary existing model developed by Baker et al. were evaluated in validation group.
RESULTS: The two new models had similar mean percentage errors (MPEs) (3.9% vs 3.9%) and proportions of pregnancies with an MPE < 10% (92.2% vs 90.2%); the model incorporating volume and MRI-to-delivery had relatively higher proportions of pregnancies with an MPE < 5% (72.5% vs 64.7%) and EFWs in agreement with the birth weights. The error in the Baker model was almost twice that in the new models.
CONCLUSION: The accuracy of foetal weight estimation more than one week before delivery using the model developed by Baker et al. was poor and was significantly improved by the new models. A combination of the foetal body volume and MRI-to-delivery interval will enable the more accurate determination of the EFWs.
引用
- Liao K, Tang L, Peng C, et al. Two new models for the estimation of foetal weight more than a week before delivery: An MRI study. Eur J Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31623899. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2019.06.026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。