肩关节盂唇撕裂的评估:双能CT关节造影与MR关节造影的比较
前瞻性研究纳入47例连续患者,同日行双能CT关节造影(DE-CTA)与MR关节造影(MRA),以手术为参考标准比较诊断盂唇撕裂的准确性。DE-CTA与MRA诊断性能无差异,DE-CTA的AUC较MRA无显著提高(p=0.217)。
要点
- DE-CTA与MRA诊断盂唇撕裂的敏感度和特异度相近,AUC无显著差异。
- DE-CTA读者间一致性为中等(k=0.76),读者内一致性接近完美(k=0.82)。
- 标准CTA诊断敏感度84.2%~84.2%,特异度77.8%~88.9%,与MRA相仿。
核心结论
- DE-CTA与MRA在诊断盂唇撕裂方面性能无差异。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性、经机构审查委员会批准的研究,纳入2017年1月至2018年10月间47例连续患者(男28例,女19例,平均年龄34.2岁),所有患者同日行DE-CTA和MRA,以手术为参考标准。
诊断标准与关键数值
- MRA(读者3)诊断盂唇撕裂的敏感度84.2%、特异度77.8%。
- 标准CTA(读者1)敏感度84.2%、特异度77.8%;(读者2)敏感度84.2%、特异度88.9%。
- DE-CTA(读者1)敏感度89.5%、特异度88.9%;(读者2)敏感度92.1%、特异度88.9%。
- DE-CTA较MRA的AUC无显著提高(p=0.217),标准CTA较MRA亦无显著提高(p=0.470)。
- 读者间一致性:CTA k=0.84(接近完美),DE-CTA k=0.76(中等);读者内一致性:CTA k=0.88,DE-CTA k=0.82(均接近完美)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To compare the diagnostic accuracy of dual-energy computed tomography arthrography (DE-CTA) and magnetic resonance arthrography (MRA) of the shoulder in depicting glenoid labral tears.
METHODS: This prospective institutional review board-approved study included 47 consecutive patients (28 males, 19 females; mean age of 34.2 years) studied between January 2017 and October 2018. All patients underwent DE-CTA and MRA the same day. Two radiologists (25 and 11 years of experience, respectively), blinded to clinical data, evaluated the presence labral tears on virtual-blended 120 kV standard CTA and on DE-CTA images. A third radiologist (18 years of experience) evaluated the MRA images. Diagnostic accuracy values were calculated by using surgery as standard of reference. Inter-observer and intra-observer agreements were calculated with k statistics. A value of p < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
RESULTS: Surgery revealed the presence of labral tears in 38/47 patients (80.9%). Sensitivity and specificity values in diagnosing labral tears were 84.2% and 77.8% for MRA (Reader 3), 84.2% and 77.8% for CTA (Reader 1), 84.2% and 88.9% for CTA (Reader 2), 89.5% and 88.9% for DE-CTA (Reader 1), and 92.1% and 88.9% for DE-CTA (Reader 2). A nonsignificant increase in AUC values with respect to MRA was obtained by reading the CTA (p = 0.470) and DE-CTA dataset (p = 0.217), respectively. Inter-observer agreements were near perfect for CTA (k = 0.84) and substantial for DE-CTA reading (k = 0.76). Intra-observer agreements were near perfect both for CTA (k = 0.88) and for DE-CTA reading (k = 0.82).
CONCLUSION: DE-CTA and MRA were not different in terms of diagnostic performance.
引用
- Foti G, Mantovani W, Catania M, et al. Evaluation of glenoid labral tears: comparison between dual-energy CT arthrography and MR arthrography of the shoulder. Radiol Med. 2019. PMID: 31541346. doi:10.1007/s11547-019-01083-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。