优化CT检测溶骨性和硬化性骨病灶的辐射剂量:一项体模研究
该体模研究比较常规协议(STD,13 mGy)与六种递减剂量水平对腰椎和骨盆溶骨性及硬化性骨病灶的检出能力,采用迭代重建(IR3至IR5)及基于任务的图像质量指标(NPS、TTF、可检测性指数d')联合主观分析。结果显示在IR4下CTDIvol 3至4 mGy、IR5下1至2 mGy时d'与STD相近,IR4主观图像质量合格而IR5因图像平滑被拒绝;最终在相同d'下剂量较STD降低74%,腰椎和骨盆的CTDIvol均为3.4 mGy。
要点
- 在体模上,CTDIvol 3.4 mGy联合高等级迭代重建可获得与常规协议(13 mGy)相当的溶骨性和硬化性骨病灶检出图像质量。
- 与常规协议相比,腰椎和骨盆的辐射剂量可降低74%。
- 基于可检测性指数的任务型图像质量评估是连接物理指标与主观图像分析的客观方法。
核心结论
- CTDIvol低至3.4 mGy联合高等级迭代重建,在客观和主观分析中均能为腰椎和骨盆溶骨性及硬化性骨病灶的检出提供合适的图像质量。
研究设计与样本
- 体模研究,使用常规协议(STD,13 mGy)及六种递减剂量水平扫描,以CTDIvol评估辐射剂量。
- STD协议采用迭代重建第3级(IR3)和1 mm层厚重建,其余协议采用最高IR等级和3 mm层厚重建。
- 采用噪声功率谱(NPS)、任务型传递函数(TTF)和可检测性指数(d')进行定量分析,并用特定软件(imQuest)计算。
- d'针对溶骨性和硬化性骨病灶两种成像任务计算,并在拟人体模上进行主观分析以验证不同剂量下的图像质量。
诊断标准与关键数值
- IR4联合CTDIvol 3至4 mGy时d'值与STD协议相似。
- IR5联合CTDIvol 1至2 mGy时d'值与STD协议相似。
- 主观分析验证IR4图像质量合格,IR5因图像平滑被拒绝。
- 在相同d'下,剂量较STD协议降低74%,腰椎和骨盆的CTDIvol均为3.4 mGy。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To determine the best compromise between low radiation dose and suitable image quality for the detection of lytic and sclerotic bone lesions of the lumbar spine and pelvis.
METHODS: A phantom was scanned using the routine protocol (STD, 13 mGy) and six decreasing dose levels. Raw data were reconstructed using level 3 of iterative reconstruction (IR3) with 1-mm slice thickness for the STD protocol and highest IR levels with 3-mm slice thickness for the others. CTDIvol was used for radiation dose assessment. Quantitative criteria (noise power spectrum [NPS], task-based transfer function [TTF], and the detectability index [d']), as well as qualitative analysis, were used to compare protocols. NPS and TTF were computed using specific software (imQuest). d' was computed for two imaging tasks: lytic and sclerotic bone lesions. A subjective analysis was performed to validate the image quality obtained on the anthropomorphic phantom with the different dose values.
RESULTS: Similar d' values were found for CTDIvol from 3 to 4 mGy with IR4 and from 1 to 2 mGy for IR5 compared with d' values using the STD protocol. Image quality was validated subjectively for IR4 but rejected for IR5 (image smoothing). Finally, for the same d', the dose was reduced by 74% compared with the STD protocol, with the CTDIvol being 3.4 mGy for the lumbar spine and for the pelvis.
CONCLUSION: A dose level as low as 3.4 mGy, in association with high levels of IR, provides suitable image quality for the detection of lytic and sclerotic bone lesions of the lumbar spine and pelvis.
KEY POINTS: • A CTDI volof 3.4 mGy, in association with high iterative reconstruction level, provides suitable image quality for the detection of lytic and sclerotic bone lesions, both at objective and subjective analysis. • Compared with the standard protocol, radiation dose can be reduced up to 74% for the lumbar spine and pelvis. • A task-based image quality assessment using the detectability index represents an objective method for the assessment of image quality and bridges the gap between complex physical metrics and subjective image analysis.
引用
- Greffier J, Frandon J, Pereira F, et al. Optimization of radiation dose for CT detection of lytic and sclerotic bone lesions: a phantom study. Eur Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31506818. doi:10.1007/s00330-019-06425-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。