产前尿路扩张共识分类系统的观察者间信度
本研究回顾性纳入300例孕28至40周因尿路扩张接受产前超声的胎儿,由5名有经验的超声医师独立评分,评估产前尿路扩张(UTD)分级系统各组分及总分的观察者间信度。结果显示UTD风险评分的观察者间一致性为中等(κ=0.657),高于SFU系统的fair一致性(κ=0.368),但肾实质外观的一致性最低(κ=0.225)。
要点
- UTD风险评分总体观察者间一致性为中等(κ=0.657),优于SFU系统(κ=0.368)。
- 肾实质外观的一致性最低(κ=0.225),是评分变异的主要来源。
- 46.3%的病例被至少2名读者赋予不同的UTD风险评分。
核心结论
- 产前UTD分级系统的观察者间一致性为中等(κ=0.657),优于SFU系统(κ=0.368)。
- 肾实质外观的一致性最低(κ=0.225),可能导致评分变异。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入孕28至40周因UTD接受产前超声检查的300例胎儿。
- 由5名有经验的超声医师(1名母胎医学专家和4名放射科医师)独立审阅全部图像。
- 分配UTD评分(正常、A1或A2/3)和SFU评分,采用Fleiss κ统计量评估观察者间一致性。
诊断标准与关键数值
- UTD风险评分总体观察者间一致性κ=0.657(95%CI 0.632–0.683),P<.001。
- 5名读者对53.7%的病例赋予相同的UTD风险评分。
- 46.3%(139/300)的病例被至少2名读者赋予不同的UTD风险评分,1.7%(5/300)的病例被赋予全部3种UTD风险评分。
- 18.0%(54/300)的病例中至少2名读者分配的UTD评分与其他读者不同。
- 肾实质外观的一致性最低,κ=0.225;SFU系统的一致性为fair,κ=0.368(P<.001)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 产前UTD分级系统在读者间的一致性为中等,可用于产前尿路扩张的风险分层。
- 肾实质外观的判读一致性最低,阅片时需注意该征象的判读差异。
- 与SFU系统相比,产前UTD系统在读者间显示出更好的一致性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: The consensus classification system for urinary tract dilatation (UTD) was designed to be more objective and reproducible than previously used systems. We sought to evaluate interobserver reliability of UTD components and overall scores in a prenatal population undergoing third-trimester ultrasound examinations.
METHODS: We retrospectively identified patients who underwent antenatal ultrasound examinations for UTD between 28 and 40 weeks' gestation. All images from individual studies of 300 fetuses were reviewed independently by 5 experienced sonologists (1 maternal-fetal medicine specialist and 4 radiologists). Urinary tract dilatation scores (normal, A1, or A2/3) and Society for Fetal Urology (SFU) scores were assigned. Interobserver agreement between raters was evaluated with the Fleiss κ statistic.
RESULTS: Overall interobserver agreement for the antenatal UTD risk score showed substantial agreement among all 5 readers (κ = 0.657 [95% confidence interval, 0.632, 0.683]; P < .001). All 5 readers applied the same UTD risk score in 53.7% of cases. Some variability in the antenatal UTD score and individual elements was observed. At least 2 UTD risk scores were assigned to a specific individual patient in 46.3% of cases (139 of 300), and all 3 UTD risk scores were assigned to a specific individual patient in 1.7% of cases (5 of 300). In 18.0% of cases (54 of 300), at least 2 readers assigned a UTD score different from that assigned by the other readers. Agreement was lowest for parenchymal appearance (κ = 0.225). Agreement for the SFU system was fair (κ = 0.368; P < .001).
CONCLUSIONS: Interobserver agreement for the antenatal UTD grading system was substantial. Compared to the SFU system, the antenatal UTD system showed better agreement among readers.
引用
- Nelson CP, Heller HT, Benson CB, et al. Interobserver Reliability of the Antenatal Consensus Classification System for Urinary Tract Dilatation. J Ultrasound Med. 2019. PMID: 31515836. doi:10.1002/jum.15133
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。