文献速递介入泌尿生殖技术与安全DSA

精索静脉曲张栓塞术:在线患者信息的质量与可读性评估

Varicocele Embolization: An Assessment of the Quality and Readability of Online Patient Information.
PubMed 文献 · Acad Radiol · 2019-09-04

研究评估了患者可获取的精索静脉曲张栓塞术在线信息的质量与可读性,使用DISCERN评分、JAMA基准标准、HONcode认证及多种可读性工具分析网页。结果显示信息质量总体为「尚可」,但JAMA基准依从率仅13.5%,可读性平均为9年级水平;科学期刊质量最高但网页平均年龄11.2年,营利性组织网页更新最快(平均2.7年)但质量评分最低。

要点

  • 在线精索静脉曲张栓塞术信息质量总体为「尚可」,但JAMA基准依从率仅13.5%。
  • 科学期刊网页质量评分最高,但平均网页年龄11.2年,可读性对公众有挑战。
  • 营利性组织网页数量更多、更新更快(平均2.7年),但信息质量评分最低。

核心结论

  • 患者可获取的在线精索静脉曲张栓塞术信息质量「尚可」,但JAMA基准依从性差。
  • 营利性组织网页更多且显著更新,但信息质量评分显著更低。
  • 科学期刊质量更高,但对普通公众阅读更具挑战性。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究为网页质量评估,未报告样本量、中心数及参考标准。
  • 生成适用且常用的检索词列表,在五个最常用的英语搜索引擎中评估以确定两个最常用检索词。
  • 对两个检索词在每个搜索引擎返回的前25个网页进行分析,排除重复网页、非文本内容(如视频或音频)及付费墙后网页。
  • 使用DISCERN评分、JAMA基准标准、HONcode认证、Flesch阅读易读性评分、Flesch-Kincaid年级水平及Gunning-Fog指数等验证工具分析质量与可读性,并记录网页年龄、排名、作者及发布者等次要特征。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • DISCERN评分显示网站提供信息的平均质量为「尚可」。
  • JAMA基准标准依从率为13.5%。
  • Flesch-Kincaid可读性测试显示平均阅读水平为「9年级」。
  • 科学期刊质量评分最高,但网页平均年龄为11.2年。
  • 营利性组织网页平均年龄2.7年,为第二新,但信息质量评分最低。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 作者认为这些发现呼吁制作高质量且易于理解的介入放射学内容,以便医生可靠地引导患者获取信息。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

AIMS AND OBJECTIVES: Varicocele embolization is a growing treatment modality owing to the safety, efficacy, and quick return to work following the procedure. The internet is the most dominant source of information for many. We aimed to assess the quality of information accessible by patients considering treatment.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: A list of applicable, commonly used searchable terms was generated. Each term was assessed across the five most-used English language search engines to determine the two most commonly used terms. These two terms were then investigated across each search engine, with the first 25 web pages returned by each engine included for analysis. Duplicate web pages, nontext content such as video or audio, and web pages behind paywalls were excluded. Web pages were analyzed for quality and readability using validated tools including DISCERN score, JAMA Benchmark Criteria, HONcode Certification, Flesch Reading Ease Score, Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level, and Gunning-Fog Index. Secondary features including age, rank, author, and publisher were recorded.

RESULTS: The most common applicable terms were "Testicular embolization" (378,300 results) and "Varicocele embolization" (375,800 results). Mean DISCERN quality of information provided by websites is "fair"; Adherence to JAMA Benchmark Criteria was 13.5%. Flesh-Kincaid readability tests demonstrated an average "9th grade" reading level. Scientific journals showed the highest quality scores, but were least up to date with an average web page age of 11.2 years. Web pages produced by "for-profit" organizations were the second most current (average age 2.7 years), but displayed the lowest quality of information scores.

CONCLUSION: While quality of online information available to patients is "fair," adherence to JAMA benchmark criteria is poor. "For-profit" organization websites are far more numerous and significantly more up-to-date, yet showed significantly lower quality of information scores. Scientific journals were unsurprisingly of higher quality, yet more challenging for the general public to read. These findings call for the production of high-quality and comprehensible content regarding interventional radiology, where physicians can reliably direct their patients for information.

来源:Acad Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Alderson JH, O'Neil DC, Redmond CE, et al. Varicocele Embolization: An Assessment of the Quality and Readability of Online Patient Information. Acad Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31494004. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2019.08.005

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。