前列腺MRI技术参数标准化:对PI-RADSv2采集方案依从性的系统综述
该系统综述检索2016年1月后发表的前列腺MRI原创研究,评估其对PI-RADSv2最低技术参数的依从性。共纳入150项研究,仅5%报告了PI-RADSv2全部技术参数,无一项完全符合指南规格;总体19%在所有报告的MRI采集参数上符合PI-RADSv2。依从性最低的为T2加权频率平面内分辨率(12%)、扩散加权成像视野(40%)、表观扩散系数图低b值(27%)和动态对比增强成像时间分辨率(43%);报告扩散加权成像高b值的研究中仅59%遵循推荐。结论认为科学界对PI-RADSv2最低技术标准的依从性异质,需更广泛传播指南以标准化方案,并提示部分要求可能受益于简化。
要点
- 仅5%的研究报告了PI-RADSv2全部技术参数,且无一项完全符合指南规格。
- 总体仅19%的研究在所有报告的MRI采集参数上符合PI-RADSv2。
- 依从性最低的参数为T2加权频率平面内分辨率(12%)和扩散加权成像视野(40%)。
核心结论
- 科学界对PI-RADSv2最低技术标准的依从性呈异质性。
- 研究结果支持需更广泛传播PI-RADSv2指南以实现方案标准化,并提示部分要求可能受益于简化以改善临床适用性。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,广泛检索多个医学文献数据库,纳入2016年1月后发表的前列腺MRI原创研究,共150项研究。
- 记录采集方案和患者入组信息,将技术参数按是否符合相应最低技术要求进行二分类分析。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 仅5%的研究报告了PI-RADSv2文件要求的每一项技术参数,其中无一项完全符合指南规格。
- 总体19%的研究在所有报告的MRI采集参数上符合PI-RADSv2。
- 依从性最低的参数:T2加权频率平面内分辨率12%、扩散加权成像视野40%、表观扩散系数图低b值27%、动态对比增强成像时间分辨率43%。
- 报告扩散加权成像高b值的研究中仅59%遵循推荐。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 原文结论指出需更广泛传播PI-RADSv2指南以实现方案标准化,并提示部分要求可能受益于简化以改善临床适用性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: The Prostate Imaging-Reporting and Data System has been developed to standardize prostate MRI in terms of acquisition, interpretation and reporting. It received a major revision in late 2014 (PI-RADSv2). Recently, doubts have been raised on imaging facilities adherence to its acquisition protocol. With this systematic review, we assessed adherence to PI-RADSv2 minimum technical specifications in literature, to achieve a better understanding of issues limiting their diffusion.
METHOD: Multiple medical literature databases were extensively searched to retrieve original studies published after January 2016 performing prostate MRI. Information pertaining acquisition protocols and patient enrolment were recorded for analysis. Technical parameters were dichotomized in relation to adherence to the corresponding minimal technical requirements.
RESULTS: A total of 150 studies were included for analysis. Only 5% reported every technical parameter specified in the PI-RADSv2 document requirements, none of which completely met guideline specifications. Overall, 19% were in line with PI-RADSv2 for all reported MRI acquisition parameters. The adherence was lowest for T2-weighted frequency in-plane resolution (12%), diffusion-weighted imaging field of view (40%), apparent diffusion coefficient map low b-value (27%) and dynamic contrast-enhanced imaging temporal resolution (43%). Considering its role in image interpretation, it must be highlighted that only 59% of studies reporting diffusion-weighted imaging high b-value follow recommendations.
CONCLUSIONS: Adherence to PI-RADSv2 minimum technical standards is heterogeneous in the scientific community. Our findings endorse the need for greater diffusion of PI-RADSv2 guidelines to achieve protocol standardization and support the notion that some requirements might benefit from streamlining to improve clinical applicability.
引用
- Cuocolo R, Stanzione A, Ponsiglione A, et al. Prostate MRI technical parameters standardization: A systematic review on adherence to PI-RADSv2 acquisition protocol. Eur J Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31539790. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2019.108662
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。