70 kVp 单能 CT 与双能 CT 的前瞻性比较:哪种更适合低对比剂剂量的 CT 血管成像?
本研究前瞻性纳入 63 例接受 180 mgI/kg 对比剂 CT 血管成像的患者,随机分为 70 kVp 单能组(32 例)和双源双能组(31 例),双能组重建 40–100 keV 虚拟单能图像。结果显示 40 keV 图像 CNR 最高,但 70 kVp 图像的 SNR、CNR 和 CNR 品质因数均更高,且除升主动脉和上腹主动脉外,各动脉主观可见度评分也优于 40 keV。
要点
- 低对比剂剂量(180 mgI/kg)CT 血管成像中,70 kVp 单能图像的 SNR、CNR 和 CNR 品质因数均优于双能 40 keV 虚拟单能图像。
- 除升主动脉和上腹主动脉外,70 kVp 对全身各动脉的主观可见度评分优于 40 keV 虚拟单能图像。
- 70 kVp 单能方案与双能方案的辐射有效剂量几乎相等。
核心结论
- 70 kVp 单能 CT 在 180 mgI/kg 对比剂剂量下主动脉强化程度低于双能 CT 40 keV 虚拟单能图像,但客观和主观图像质量均更高。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性随机对照研究,共纳入 63 例接受 180 mgI/kg 对比剂 CT 血管成像的患者。
- A 组 32 例采用 70 kVp 单能 CT 扫描,B 组 31 例采用双源双能 CT 扫描。
- 双能组在 40–100 keV 范围内以 10 keV 为间隔重建虚拟单能图像。
- 计算主动脉强化、对比噪声比(CNR)、信噪比、CNR 品质因数和有效剂量。
- 由 3 名放射科医师采用 4 分法对整体图像质量和各动脉可见度进行主观评分。
关键影像表现/征象
- 在虚拟单能图像中,40 keV 图像的 CNR 最高。
- 70 kVp 图像的主动脉强化程度显著低于 40 keV 图像(p < 0.001)。
- 70 kVp 图像的信噪比、CNR 和 CNR 品质因数均显著高于 40 keV 图像(分别为 p < 0.001、p < 0.05、p < 0.05)。
- 除升主动脉和上腹主动脉外,70 kVp 对各动脉的主观可见度评分优于 40 keV 图像。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 主观图像质量与各动脉可见度采用 4 分法评分。
- 虚拟单能图像在 40–100 keV 范围内以 10 keV 为间隔重建,其中 40 keV 图像的 CNR 最高。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 在低对比剂剂量(180 mgI/kg)CT 血管成像中,70 kVp 单能方案可获得优于双能 40 keV 虚拟单能图像的客观图像质量和主观动脉可见度。
- 70 kVp 方案的辐射有效剂量与双能方案几乎相等。
- 70 kVp 图像的主动脉强化程度低于 40 keV 虚拟单能图像,阅片时需结合强化程度与噪声水平综合评估图像质量。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: To compare the objective and subjective image qualities between single-energy computed tomography (CT) at 70 kVp and virtual monoenergetic imaging (VMI) of dual-source dual-energy CT for CT angiography with 180 mgI/kg.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Total 63 patients scanned with 180 mgI/kg were randomly divided into two groups: Group A (32 patients) underwent CT angiography at 70-kVp, and Group B (31 patients) underwent dual-energy CT. VMI sets were generated at 10-keV increments between 40 and 100 keV. We calculated aortic attenuation, contrast-to-noise-ratio (CNR), signal-to-noise-ratio, figure of merit of CNR, and effective dose for each protocol. Three radiologists scored overall image quality and various arteries' visibility using a four-point scale. Quantitative and qualitative comparisons between 70 kVp and VMI with the highest CNR were performed with the two-tailed t test or Kruskal-Wallis test.
RESULTS: The 40-keV images offered the highest CNR among VMIs. Aortic attenuation at 70 kVp was significantly lower than that at 40 keV (p < 0.001). However, the signal-to-noise-ratio, CNR, and figure of merit of CNR were significantly higher at 70 kVp than those at 40-keV (p < 0.001, p < 0.05, and p < 0.05, respectively). The effective dose of each group was almost equal. The qualitative visibility scores for various arteries, except the ascending and upper-abdominal aorta, were also better at 70 kVp than those at 40 keV.
CONCLUSION: Aortic attenuation at 70 kVp with 180 mg I/kg was lower than that of VMI at 40 keV, and the objective and subjective image qualities were higher at 70 kVp than those at 40 keV.
引用
- Yoshida M, Nakaura T, Sentaro T, et al. Prospective Comparison of 70-kVp Single-Energy CT versus Dual-Energy CT: Which is More Suitable for CT Angiography with Low Contrast Media Dosage? Acad Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31537504. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2019.07.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。