卢旺达住院医师实施的床旁肺部超声与胸部X线在胸腔置管后气胸随访中的准确性比较
在卢旺达,51例胸腔置管后气胸随访患者中,经短期培训的住院医师实施床旁肺部超声并以专家判读为参考标准,其诊断气胸的敏感度100%、特异度96%;临床医师判读胸片敏感度48%、特异度100%;超声出结果时间显著短于胸片(平均396分钟 vs 1335分钟,P=0.0001)。
要点
- 住院医师实施肺部超声诊断气胸的敏感度100%、特异度96%,与专家判读一致性极好(κ=0.96)。
- 临床医师判读胸片诊断气胸的敏感度仅48%、特异度100%,与放射科医师判读一致性仅为中等(κ=0.60)。
- 肺部超声出结果时间显著短于胸片(平均396分钟 vs 1335分钟,P=0.0001)。
核心结论
- 在卢旺达本研究中,住院医师实施的肺部超声是更快捷且敏感度优于临床医师判读胸片的影像方式,可用于胸腔置管后气胸随访。
- 肺部超声可作为气胸随访的有价值影像工具,尤其在资源有限环境中。
研究设计与样本
- 研究类型为诊断准确性研究,在卢旺达开展,为期8个月,共纳入51例接受胸片随访气胸的参与者。
- 经短期培训的卢旺达外科住院医师在不知胸片结果的情况下实施并判读肺部超声,临床治疗医师判读胸片以决定治疗。
- 肺部超声 later 由超声专家复核,胸片由放射科医师复核,以专家肺部超声判读为参考标准。
关键影像表现/征象
- 原文未报告具体影像征象。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 以专家肺部超声判读为参考标准,住院医师肺部超声诊断气胸的敏感度为100%(95%CI 85%-100%),特异度为96%(95%CI 82%-100%)。
- 临床医师判读胸片诊断气胸的敏感度为48%(95%CI 27%-69%),特异度为100%(95%CI 88%-100%)。
- 住院医师与专家肺部超声判读的一致性极好(κ=0.96),临床医师与放射科医师胸片判读的一致性仅为中等(κ=0.60)。
- 肺部超声出结果时间显著短于胸片(平均396分钟 vs 1335分钟,P=0.0001)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 经短期培训的住院医师实施床旁肺部超声可用于胸腔置管后气胸随访,较临床医师判读胸片敏感度更高且出结果更快。
- 临床医师判读胸片诊断气胸敏感度较低(48%),可能漏诊气胸。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to evaluate the accuracy and timeliness of resident-performed point-of-care lung ultrasound (LUS) examinations for the follow-up of pneumothorax (PTX) after tube thoracostomy.
METHODS: After brief training, Rwandan surgical residents blinded to chest radiography (CXR) performed and interpreted LUS examinations for PTX in participants undergoing CXR for PTX follow-up. Treating clinicians interpreted CXR for the presence of PTX for therapeutic decisions. Lung ultrasound was later reviewed by ultrasound experts, and CXR was reviewed by a radiologist. We defined expert LUS interpretation as the reference standard. The sensitivity and specificity of resident-performed LUS examinations for diagnosing PTX were calculated. We assessed agreement between trained resident versus expert LUS and clinician versus radiology CXR using the Cohen κ coefficient. We compared the time to results between LUS and CXR.
RESULTS: Over an 8-month period, 51 participants were enrolled. Compared to expert LUS interpretation, the sensitivity and specificity (95% confidence intervals) of resident LUS were 100% (85%-100%) and 96% (82%-100%), respectively, whereas the sensitivity and specificity of clinician-interpreted CXR were 48% (27%-69%) and 100% (88%-100%). The agreement between resident and expert LUS was excellent (κ = 0.96), whereas the agreement between clinician and radiologist CXR was only moderate (κ = 0.60). The time to results was significantly longer for CXR than LUS (mean, 1335 versus 396 minutes; P = .0001).
CONCLUSIONS: A resident-performed LUS examination was a quicker imaging modality with superior sensitivity compared to clinician-interpreted CXR for PTX follow-up after tube thoracostomy in this Rwandan study. Lung ultrasound can be a valuable imaging tool for PTX follow-up, especially in resource-limited settings.
引用
- Shumbusho JP, Duanmu Y, Kim SH, et al. Accuracy of Resident-Performed Point-of-Care Lung Ultrasound Examinations Versus Chest Radiography in Pneumothorax Follow-up After Tube Thoracostomy in Rwanda. J Ultrasound Med. 2019. PMID: 31490569. doi:10.1002/jum.15126
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。