放射科住院医师推荐信中的性别与种族偏倚
该研究回顾性分析2015至2016面试季杜克大学736名放射科住院医师申请者的2624封推荐信,用文本分析软件统计能动性与 communal 词汇频率。结果显示女性申请者被描述为更具能动性(IRR=1.08,P<.05),黑人和拉丁裔申请者较白人和亚裔更少被描述为具有能动性(IRR=0.932,P<.05);女性写信者使用更多能动性(IRR=1.09,P<.05)和 communal(IRR=1.12,P<.01)词汇,高级职称者较少使用能动性(IRR=0.95,P<.05)和 communal(IRR=0.88,P<.01)词汇。结论认为推荐信中语言使用因申请者和写信者人口学特征而异。
要点
- 女性申请者被描述为更具能动性(IRR=1.08,P<.05)。
- 黑人和拉丁裔申请者较白人和亚裔更少被描述为具有能动性(IRR=0.932,P<.05)。
- 女性写信者使用更多能动性(IRR=1.09,P<.05)和 communal(IRR=1.12,P<.01)词汇。
核心结论
- 放射科住院医师推荐信中能动性与 communal 语言的使用程度因申请者和写信者的人口学特征而异。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析2015至2016面试季杜克大学736名诊断放射科住院医师申请者的2624封推荐信,共976489词,使用计算机文本分析软件和多水平负二项回归比较语言计数差异。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 女性申请者被描述为更具能动性(IRR=1.08,P<.05)。
- 黑人和拉丁裔申请者较白人和亚裔更少被描述为具有能动性(IRR=0.932,P<.05)。
- 女性写信者较男性写信者使用更多能动性(IRR=1.09,P<.05)和 communal(IRR=1.12,P<.01)词汇。
- 高级职称教师较初级教师更少使用能动性(IRR=0.95,P<.05)和 communal(IRR=0.88,P<.01)词汇。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Perceptions of agency and communality vary by race and gender, which may be contributing to the persistent gender and racial inequality in radiology. The objective of this study was to determine if there are differences in the use of agentic and communal language in letters of recommendation for radiology residency programs based on the demographics of the applicant and letter writer.
METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed letters of recommendation for 736 diagnostic radiology residency applicants to Duke University from the 2015 to 2016 interview season. We then used computerized text analysis software to calculate the frequency of agentic and communal terms and multilevel negative binominal regression to compare differences in count by applicant and letter writer demographics.
RESULTS: We analyzed 2,624 letters of recommendation, comprising 976,489 words. The majority of applicants were male (75%, 549 of 736) and white or Asian (77%, 565 of 736). Letter writers, who were mostly male (75%, 1,979 of 2,624) and of senior rank (50%, 1,313 of 2,624), described female applicants as more agentic than men (incidence rate ratio [IRR] = 1.08, P < .05) and described blacks and Latinx applicants as less agentic than whites and Asians (IRR = 0.932, P < .05). Secondary analysis showed that female letters writers described applicants as more agentic (IRR = 1.09, P < .05) and more communal (IRR = 1.12, P < .01) than did male writers, and senior rank faculty used agentic (IRR = 0.95, P < .05) and communal (IRR = 0.88, P < .01) language less often than did junior faculty.
CONCLUSION: The extent to which agentic and communal language is used in letters of recommendation for diagnostic radiology residency programs differs by applicant and letter writer demographics.
引用
- Grimm LJ, Redmond RA, Campbell JC, et al. Gender and Racial Bias in Radiology Residency Letters of Recommendation. J Am Coll Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31494103. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2019.08.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。