肌肉剪切波弹性成像中哪些混杂因素影响最大及如何最小化:弹性模体、离体猪肌肉与志愿者商用系统研究
研究在弹性模体、离体猪肌肉和健康志愿者小腿肌中评估感兴趣区、软件版本、肌纤维方向与预载荷对剪切波速度的影响,发现肌肉张力、纤维方向、水平ROI大小和插入深度依次为主要变异来源,并提出控制混杂因素的建议以降低变异系数。
要点
- 肌肉张力是剪切波速度变异的首要混杂因素,其次为纤维方向、水平ROI大小和插入深度。
- 探头平行于肌纤维、肌肉拉伸及增大水平ROI均使剪切波速度显著升高。
- 控制方案下若临床考虑混杂因素,变异系数可显著降低。
核心结论
- 肌肉张力、纤维方向、水平ROI大小和插入深度依次为剪切波速度主要变异贡献因素,基于结果提供减少肌肉骨骼弹性成像混杂因素影响的建议并讨论混杂机制与权衡。
研究设计与样本
- 研究在各向同性弹性模体和离体猪肌肉中用商用临床超声系统评估剪切波速度,并在健康志愿者放松与拉伸小腿肌(距小腿关节背伸)中采集平行和横向探头方向、不同ROI和软件版本的剪切波速度,另分析中间探头-纤维对齐的影响,最终用第二项力控制志愿者研究(小腿等长负荷、纤维方向和ROI明确)最小化混杂因素对重现性的影响,共采集2046幅体内剪切波弹性成像图像。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 基于研究结果提供建议以最小化肌肉骨骼弹性成像中混杂因素的影响,并讨论主要混杂机制及混杂变量间的权衡。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
The goal of the study was to investigate the quantitative impact of region of interest (ROI), software choice, muscle fiber orientation and preload tension on shear wave velocity (SWV). First, SWV was assessed in an isotropic elasticity phantom and ex vivo porcine muscle using a commercially available clinical ultrasound system. Secondly, SWV was acquired in relaxed and stretched calf muscles of healthy volunteers (dorsal extension of the talocrural joint), for both parallel and transverse probe direction to the fibers, as well as for different ROIs and software versions. The effect of intermediate probe-fiber alignments was also analyzed. Finally, the impact of confounding factors on SWV reproducibility was minimized with a second force-controlled volunteer study, in which the calf was isometrically loaded, and fiber orientation and ROI were well-defined. 2046 in vivoSWE images were acquired to analyze SWV reproducibility with different confounder settings. In healthy volunteers, the main variance-contributing factors were in order of importance muscle tension, fiber orientation, horizontal ROI size and insertion depth. Regression analysis showed significantly reduced SWV with increasing insertion depth for each study material. Parallel probe-fiber orientation, muscle stretch and increasing horizontal ROI size led to significantly higher SWV. Based on the results of the study, we provide recommendations to minimize the impact of confounders in musculoskeletal elastography and discuss the main confounding mechanisms and trade-offs between confounding variables. Coefficients of variation can be significantly reduced with a controlled protocol, if the confounders are clinically taken into account.
引用
- Ruby L, Mutschler T, Martini K, et al. Which Confounders Have the Largest Impact in Shear Wave Elastography of Muscle and How Can They be Minimized? An Elasticity Phantom, Ex Vivo Porcine Muscle and Volunteer Study Using a Commercially Available System. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2019. PMID: 31375216. doi:10.1016/j.ultrasmedbio.2019.06.417
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。