筛查场景中合成数字乳腺X线摄影联合断层合成的应用与影响调查结果
该调查于2018年6月向乳腺影像学会会员发放在线问卷,评估筛查中合成数字乳腺X线摄影(SM)联合数字乳腺断层合成(DBT)的使用情况与态度。2600名会员中312名回复(12%),96%具备DBT能力、83%具备SM能力;仅52%在多数DBT筛查中以SM替代DM,最常见担忧为钙化表征(61%)和图像质量下降(31%)。
要点
- 96%的受访者具备DBT能力,83%具备SM能力,但仅52%在多数DBT筛查中以SM替代DM。
- SM最常被提及的优点为降低剂量(85%)和增加病灶可见性(27%)。
- SM最常被提及的缺点为钙化表征(61%)和图像质量下降(31%)。
核心结论
- 多数使用DBT筛查的放射科医生已具备SM,但仅一半以SM替代DM;尽管SM-DBT的不良筛查结局报告较少,放射科医生仍对图像质量尤其是钙化表征存在担忧。
研究设计与样本
- 基于乳腺影像学会会员的在线调查研究,于2018年6月发放问卷,2600名会员中312名回复(12%),研究经机构审查委员会豁免;采用χ2检验比较组间应答频率。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 在DBT筛查中,40%的受访者联合使用SM与DM,52%在多数DBT筛查中使用SM而不使用DM。
- 对SM的总体满意度为3.4分(5分制,1-5分)。
- 多数受访者不确定SM-DBT是否改变癌症检出率(44%)或召回率(30%),报告不良结局者较少:召回率升高6%、癌症检出率降低1%。
- 无SM者最常提及的原因为成本或管理因素(32%)和图像质量担忧(32%)。
局限性
- 2600名会员中仅312名回复,应答率12%。
- 多数受访者不确定癌症检出率(44%)或召回率(30%)是否改变。
- 放射科医生对图像质量尤其是钙化表征存在担忧(61%报告钙化表征为缺点,31%报告图像质量下降)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Synthesized digital mammography (SM) was developed to replace digital mammography (DM) in digital breast tomosynthesis (DBT) imaging to reduce radiation dose. This survey assessed utilization and attitudes regarding SM in DBT screening. The study was institutional review board exempt. An online survey was sent to members of the Society of Breast Imaging in June 2018. Questions included practice information, utilization of DBT and SM, perception of change in recall rates (RRs) and cancer detection rates (CDRs) with SM-DBT versus DM-DBT, and attitudes regarding SM versus DM in DBT screening. χ2 Tests were used to compare response frequencies across groups. In all, 312 of 2,600 Society of Breast Imaging members responded to the survey (12%). Of respondents, 96% reported DBT capability, and 83% reported SM capability. Of those without SM, the most cited reasons were cost or administration and image quality concerns (both 32%). In addition, 40% reported combined SM and DM use in DBT screens, and 52% reported SM use without DM in the majority of DBT screens. The overall satisfaction with SM was 3.4 of 5 (1-5 scale). Most cited SM advantages were decreased dose (85%) and increased lesion conspicuity (27%). The most cited SM disadvantages were calcification characterization (61%) and decreased image quality (31%). Most respondents were unsure if CDRs changed (44%) and RR changed (30%) with few reporting adverse outcomes (6% RR increase, 1% CDR decrease). Most radiologists screening with DBT have SM, but only one-half have replaced DM with SM. Despite few reported adverse screening outcomes with SM-DBT, radiologists have concerns about image quality, specifically calcification characterization.
引用
- Zuckerman SP, Sprague BL, Weaver DL, et al. Survey Results Regarding Uptake and Impact of Synthetic Digital Mammography With Tomosynthesis in the Screening Setting. J Am Coll Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31415739. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2019.07.020
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。