数字乳腺X线摄影与乳腺断层合成比较:乳腺密度对人群筛查诊断性能的影响
基于奥斯陆断层合成筛查试验的前瞻性数据,24 301名50-69岁女性接受同压缩数字乳腺X线摄影(DM)与数字乳腺断层合成(DBT)并独立双读。DBT在各密度组和年龄组真阳性率均高于DM,主要因发现更多毛刺状肿块和结构扭曲;假阳性率除极度致密乳腺外均低于DM,因不对称致密影减少。
要点
- DBT较DM提高各密度组和年龄组真阳性率,主要归因于检出更多毛刺状肿块和结构扭曲。
- DBT假阳性率在多数年龄组和密度组低于DM,因不对称致密影减少,但极度致密乳腺除外。
- 癌检出率的改善与年龄呈正相关。
核心结论
- 与DM相比,DBT在所有密度组和年龄组均检出更多癌症,尤其是毛刺状肿块和结构扭曲类癌症。
- DBT的癌检出率改善与年龄呈正相关。
- DBT使假阳性发现减少(因不对称致密影减少),但极度致密乳腺除外(0.1%,P = .82)。
研究设计与样本
- 奥斯陆断层合成筛查试验为前瞻性研究,2010年11月至2012年12月纳入24 301名50-69岁女性(平均年龄59.1岁±5.7)。
- 参与者接受同压缩DM和DBT,DM与DM加DBT两种阅片模式均独立双读,8名有经验放射科医生用五点量表评定恶性概率。
- 随访2年评估 interval cancer(间期癌),乳腺密度用自动容积软件评估(分级1-4)。
关键影像表现/征象
- DBT检出更多毛刺状肿块和结构扭曲(密度评分2和3 P < .001;55-69岁女性 P < .05)。
- DBT假阳性率低于DM,归因于不对称致密影减少(P ≤ .001),但极度致密乳腺除外(0.1%,P = .82)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 真阳性率DBT高于DM:密度组差异范围12%-24%(密度评分2和3 P < .001,密度评分1和4 P > .05)。
- 真阳性率DBT高于DM:年龄组差异范围15%-35%(所有年龄组 P < .05)。
- 假阳性率DBT低于DM:所有年龄组范围-0.6%至-1.2%(P < .01)。
- 假阳性率DBT低于DM:密度组范围-0.7至-1.0%(P < .005),极度致密乳腺除外(0.1%,P = .82)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 原文结论认为DBT较DM在所有密度和年龄组检出更多癌症,尤其毛刺状肿块和结构扭曲。
- 原文结论认为DBT使假阳性发现减少(因不对称致密影减少),但极度致密乳腺除外。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BackgroundPrevious studies comparing digital breast tomosynthesis (DBT) to digital mammography (DM) have shown conflicting results regarding breast density and diagnostic performance.PurposeTo compare true-positive and false-positive interpretations in DM versus DBT according to volumetric density, age, and mammographic findings.Materials and MethodsFrom November 2010 to December 2012, 24 301 women aged 50-69 years (mean age, 59.1 years ± 5.7) were prospectively included in the Oslo Tomosynthesis Screening Trial. Participants received same-compression DM and DBT with independent double reading for both DM and DM plus DBT reading modes. Eight experienced radiologists rated the images by using a five-point scale for probability of malignancy. Participants were followed up for 2 years to assess for interval cancers. Breast density was assessed by using automatic volumetric software (scale, 1-4). Differences in true-positive rates, false-positive rates, and mammographic findings were assessed by using confidence intervals (Newcombe paired method) and P values (McNemar and χ2 tests).ResultsThe true-positive rate of DBT was higher than that of DM for density groups (range, 12%-24%; P < .001 for density scores of 2 and 3, and P > .05 for density scores of 1 and 4) and age groups (range, 15%-35%; P < .05 for all age groups), mainly due to the higher number of spiculated masses and architectural distortions found at DBT (P < .001 for density scores of 2 and 3; P < .05 for women aged 55-69 years). The false-positive rate was lower for DBT than for DM in all age groups (range, -0.6% to -1.2%; P < .01) and density groups (range, -0.7 to -1.0%; P < .005) owing to fewer asymmetric densities (P ≤ .001), except for extremely dense breasts (0.1%, P = .82).ConclusionDigital breast tomosynthesis enabled the detection of more cancers in all density and age groups compared with digital mammography, especially cancers classified as spiculated masses and architectural distortions. The improvement in cancer detection rate showed a positive correlation with age. With use of digital breast tomosynthesis, false-positive findings were lower due to fewer asymmetric densities, except in extremely dense breasts.© RSNA, 2019Online supplemental material is available for this article.See also the editorial by Fuchsjäger and Adelsmayr in this issue.
引用
- Østerås BH, Martinsen ACT, Gullien R, et al. Digital Mammography versus Breast Tomosynthesis: Impact of Breast Density on Diagnostic Performance in Population-based Screening. Radiology. 2019. PMID: 31407968. doi:10.1148/radiol.2019190425
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。