乳腺MRI技术质量差异研究
回顾性分析2013年连续100例至三级癌症中心寻求第二意见的外院乳腺MRI,由三名乳腺放射学专科医师和一名乳腺影像研究员依据ACR乳腺MRI认证计划盲法评估技术质量。88例来自美国机构,其中68%存在至少一项技术缺陷,最常见的为伪影(74%),其次为T2加权序列缺陷(38%)和延迟期/早期增强T1加权序列缺陷(27%/23%)。结论认为美国乳腺MRI质量存在差异,放射科医师应熟悉ACR认证要求并努力达到标准。
要点
- 美国外院乳腺MRI中68%存在至少一项技术缺陷,11%存在超过五项不同技术缺陷。
- 伪影最常见(74%),其中匀场(17例)和运动(16例)为主要原因。
- T2加权序列缺陷占38%,主要因信噪比低(25例)。
核心结论
- 研究显示美国乳腺MRI质量存在差异,放射科医师应熟悉ACR乳腺MRI认证计划的要求并努力达到预期标准,以提高患者质量与安全。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,连续纳入2013年提交至三级癌症中心寻求第二意见的100例乳腺MRI,其中88例来自美国机构。
- 由三名乳腺放射学专科医师和一名乳腺影像研究员依据ACR乳腺MRI认证计划盲法评估图像技术质量。
关键影像表现/征象
- 88例美国病例中60例(68%)存在至少一项技术缺陷,10例(11%)出现超过五种不同技术缺陷。
- 最常见的缺陷为伪影(74%),其中匀场问题17例、运动16例。
- 38%病例(33例)存在T2加权序列缺陷,主要因信噪比低(25例)。
- 27%病例(24例)存在延迟期增强T1加权序列缺陷,主要因信噪比低(21例)。
- 23%病例存在早期增强T1加权序列缺陷,主要因信噪比低(19例)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: Breast magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) quality may vary across the United States. Our aim was to investigate the quality of outside breast MRIs presenting for second opinion at a tertiary cancer center following implementation of the American College of Radiology (ACR) Breast MRI Accreditation Program.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed the technical quality of the MRI studies of 100 consecutive cases submitted for second opinion in 2013. The image quality was blindly reviewed per ACR Breast MRI Accreditation Program by three fellowship-trained breast radiologists and one breast imaging fellow.
RESULTS: In total, 88 of the 100 cases were referred from facilities in the United States. Sixty (68%) of the 88 cases had at least one technical deficiency. In 10 cases (11%), more than five different technical deficiencies occurred. The most frequently encountered deficiencies were related to artifacts (74%), with shimming (N = 17) and motion (N = 16) being the most common. In total, 38% of cases (N = 33) had a deficient T2-weighted sequence, mostly due to low signal to noise ratio (N = 25). A total of 27% cases (N = 24) had deficiencies in the delayed phase postcontrast T1-weighted sequence, mainly due to low signal to noise ratio (N = 21) and 23% had deficiencies in the early phase postcontrast T1-weighted sequence, predominantly due to low signal to noise ratio as well. (N = 19).
CONCLUSION: Our study demonstrates variability of breast MRI quality across the United States. Radiologists should become familiar with the requirements of the ACR breast MRI accreditation program and strive to meet the expected standards in order to enhance patient quality and safety.
引用
- Ruiz-Flores L, Whitman GJ, Le-Petross HTC, et al. Variation in Technical Quality of Breast MRI. Acad Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31371208. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2019.07.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。