专家共识定义的先天性子宫畸形(CUME):T形子宫的诊断标准
本研究采用CUME方法,以15位专家独立判断中最常做出的诊断(≥8/15一致)为参考标准,前瞻性评估100例子宫三维超声数据集,筛选出区分T形与正常/弓形子宫的可靠测量指标。结果显示,侧方内凹深度≥7 mm、侧方凹陷角≤130°和T角≤40°三项指标具有良好诊断准确性,三项同时满足时T形子宫诊断概率达93%。
要点
- 侧方内凹深度≥7 mm敏感度最高(95%),侧方凹陷角≤130°特异度最高(96%)。
- 三项CUME标准全部满足时93%(13/14)病例诊断为T形子宫,仅满足一项时仅10%。
- 专家主观判断一致性仅为中等(kappa=0.43),诊断T形子宫并不容易。
核心结论
- 侧方内凹深度≥7 mm、侧方凹陷角≤130°和T角≤40°三项超声测量指标具有良好诊断准确性,联合应用可提供T形子宫的高验后概率。
- 作者建议:无其他异常时,不满足或仅满足一项标准考虑为正常子宫,满足两项为交界性,三项全部满足为T形子宫。
- CUME定义的T形子宫标准可能有助于确定其患病率、临床意义和最佳管理,并可用于评估术后形态学结局。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性设计的多评估者信度/一致性和诊断准确性研究,于2017年11月至2018年12月进行。
- 样本为100例来自2014至2016年间连续入组女性的三维超声数据集,均显示子宫腔侧方内凹。
- 参考标准为15位独立专家(5名临床医生、5名外科医生、5名超声医生)对匿名冠状面图像独立判断中最常做出的诊断(≥8/15一致)。
- 另由2名经验丰富的观察者独立进行15项超声测量,评估观察者间信度。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 侧方凹陷角≤130°:敏感度80%,特异度96%,LR+ 21.3,LR- 0.21(AUC=0.95)。
- 侧方内凹深度≥7 mm:敏感度95%,特异度77.5%,LR+ 4.2,LR- 0.06(AUC=0.92)。
- T角≤40°:敏感度80%,特异度87.5%,LR+ 6.4,LR- 0.23(AUC=0.87)。
- 三项标准满足数量与专家诊断T形子宫的比例:0项为0%(0/56),1项为10%(2/20),2项为50%(5/10),3项为93%(13/14)。
- 观察者间可重复性:T角CCC=0.87,侧方内凹深度CCC=0.82,侧方凹陷角CCC=0.62。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 日常阅片可测量侧方内凹深度、侧方凹陷角和T角,按CUME标准综合判断T形子宫。
- 专家主观判断一致性仅为中等(kappa=0.43),提示仅凭肉眼判断不足以准确诊断。
- 作者建议:无其他异常时,不满足或仅满足一项标准考虑为正常,满足两项为交界性,三项全部满足为T形子宫。
局限性
- 专家间诊断一致性仅为中等(kappa=0.43),个体专家判断通常不足以准确诊断。
- 诊断标准需进一步研究以评估其临床意义和最佳管理。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To identify uterine measurements that are reliable and accurate to distinguish between T-shaped and normal/arcuate uterus, and define T-shaped uterus, using Congenital Uterine Malformation by Experts (CUME) methodology, which uses as reference standard the decision made most often by several independent experts.
METHODS: This was a prospectively planned multirater reliability/agreement and diagnostic accuracy study, performed between November 2017 and December 2018, using a sample of 100 three-dimensional (3D) datasets of different uteri with lateral uterine cavity indentations, acquired from consecutive women between 2014 and 2016. Fifteen representative experts (five clinicians, five surgeons and five sonologists), blinded to each others' opinions, examined anonymized images of the coronal plane of each uterus and provided their independent opinion as to whether it was T-shaped or normal/arcuate; this formed the basis of the CUME reference standard, with the decision made most often (i.e. that chosen by eight or more of the 15 experts) for each uterus being considered the correct diagnosis for that uterus. Two other experienced observers, also blinded to the opinions of the other experts, then performed independently 15 sonographic measurements, using the original 3D datasets of each uterus. Agreement between the diagnoses made by the 15 experts was assessed using kappa and percent agreement. The interobserver reliability of measurements was assessed using the concordance correlation coefficient (CCC). The diagnostic test accuracy was assessed using the area under the receiver-operating-characteristics curve (AUC) and the best cut-off value was assessed by calculating Youden's index, according to the CUME reference standard. Sensitivity, specificity, negative and positive likelihood ratios (LR- and LR+) and post-test probability were calculated.
RESULTS: According to the CUME reference standard, there were 20 T-shaped and 80 normal/arcuate uteri. Individual experts recognized between 5 and 35 (median, 19) T-shaped uteri on subjective judgment. The agreement among experts was 82% (kappa = 0.43). Three of the 15 sonographic measurements were identified as having good diagnostic test accuracy, according to the CUME reference standard: lateral indentation angle (AUC = 0.95), lateral internal indentation depth (AUC = 0.92) and T-angle (AUC = 0.87). Of these, T-angle had the best interobserver reproducibility (CCC = 0.87 vs 0.82 vs 0.62 for T-angle vs lateral indentation depth vs lateral indentation angle). The best cut-off values for these measurements were: lateral indentation angle ≤ 130° (sensitivity, 80%; specificity, 96%; LR+, 21.3; LR-, 0.21), lateral indentation depth ≥ 7 mm (sensitivity, 95%; specificity, 77.5%; LR+, 4.2; LR-, 0.06) and T-angle ≤ 40° (sensitivity, 80%; specificity, 87.5%; LR+, 6.4; LR-, 0.23). Most of the experts diagnosed the uterus as being T-shaped in 0% (0/56) of cases when none of these three criteria was met, in 10% (2/20) of cases when only one criterion was met, in 50% (5/10) of cases when two of the three criteria were met, and in 93% (13/14) of cases when all three criteria were met.
CONCLUSIONS: The diagnosis of T-shaped uterus is not easy; the agreement among experts was only moderate and the judgement of individual experts was commonly insufficient for accurate diagnosis. The three sonographic measurements with cut-offs that we identified (lateral internal indentation depth ≥ 7 mm, lateral indentation angle ≤ 130° and T-angle ≤ 40°) had good diagnostic test accuracy and fair-to-moderate reliability and, when applied in combination, they provided high post-test probability for T-shaped uterus. In the absence of other anomalies, we suggest considering a uterus to be normal when none or only one criterion is met, borderline when two criteria are met, and T-shaped when all three criteria are met. These three CUME criteria for defining T-shaped uterus may aid in determination of its prevalence, clinical implications and best management and in the assessment of post-surgical morphologic outcome. The CUME definition of T-shaped uterus may help in the development of interventional randomized controlled trials and observational studies and in the diagnosis of uterine morphology in everyday practice, and could be adopted by guidelines on uterine anomalies to enrich their classification systems. Copyright © 2019 ISUOG. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
引用
- Ludwin A, Coelho Neto MA, Ludwin I, et al. Congenital Uterine Malformation by Experts (CUME): diagnostic criteria for T-shaped uterus. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2020. PMID: 31432589. doi:10.1002/uog.20845
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。