ElastQ成像与SuperSonic剪切波成像二维剪切波弹性测量比较:体模研究与临床预试验
该研究用弹性体模和27例肝病儿童及年轻患者,比较ElastQ成像与SuperSonic剪切波成像的二维剪切波弹性测量。两种系统在体模中均显示高重复性(变异系数0.69%-15.82%)和极好观察者间一致性(ICC 0.992)。ElastQ成像超出范围测量和测量误差的比例显著低于SSI(P≤.003),患者肝硬度测量两系统强相关(ρ=0.955)且一致性极好(ICC 0.951)。
要点
- 体模中两系统弹性测量重复性高(变异系数0.69%-15.82%),观察者间一致性极好(ICC 0.992)。
- ElastQ成像超出范围测量和测量误差的比例显著低于SSI(P≤.003)。
- 肝病患者肝硬度测量两系统强相关(ρ=0.955)且一致性极好(ICC 0.951)。
核心结论
- ElastQ成像在体模模型中的重复性、观察者间一致性和准确性与SSI相当;预试验患者研究显示两系统肝硬度值强相关。
研究设计与样本
- 体模研究联合临床预试验;使用含5个目标弹性、2个采集深度的弹性体模,由2名放射科医师分别用ElastQ成像和SSI进行二维剪切波弹性测量;肝硬度在27例各种肝病的儿童和年轻成人患者中测量。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 体模重复性以变异系数评估(0.69%-15.82%),观察者间一致性以ICC评估(0.992);90%目标平均弹性在两种技术间(P≤.002)及两个采集深度间(P≤.004)有显著差异;ElastQ成像超出预期值范围和测量误差的比例显著低于SSI(P≤.003);患者肝硬度两系统相关ρ=0.955(P<.001),一致性ICC=0.951(P<.001)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To compare the feasibility and clinical applicability of ElastQ imaging (Philips Healthcare, Best, the Netherlands) with that of SuperSonic shear imaging (SSI; SuperSonic Imagine, Aix-en-Provence, France) using an elastographic phantom and a pilot study of patients.
METHODS: Two-dimensional shear wave elastography measurement was performed by ElastQ imaging and SSI by 2 radiologists. An elastographic phantom with 5 target elasticities at 2 acquisition depths was used. The coefficients of variation and intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) were evaluated for repeatability and interobserver agreement, respectively. The mean elasticities of the systems at each target were compared. The proportions of measurements that were out of the range of expected values and measurement errors were calculated to determine accuracy. Liver stiffness (LS) was measured by both systems in 27 children and young adult patients with various liver diseases.
RESULTS: Both systems provided high repeatability in elasticity measurements of phantom targets (coefficients of variation, 0.69%-15.82%), and there was excellent interobserver agreement (ICC, 0.992). Most (90%) mean elasticities of targets were significantly different between the techniques (P ≤ .002) and acquisition depths (P ≤ .004). ElastQ imaging had significantly lower proportions of out-of-range measurements and measurement errors (P ≤ .003) than SSI. In patients with liver disease, LS measurements of the systems were strongly correlated (ρ = 0.955; P < .001) and had excellent agreement (ICC, 0.951; P < .001).
CONCLUSIONS: ElastQ imaging had comparably good results in terms of repeatability, interobserver agreement, and accuracy in the phantom model compared with SSI. The pilot patient study showed strong correlations in LS values between the systems.
引用
- Hwang J, Yoon HM, Jung AY, et al. Comparison of 2-Dimensional Shear Wave Elastographic Measurements Using ElastQ Imaging and SuperSonic Shear Imaging: Phantom Study and Clinical Pilot Study. J Ultrasound Med. 2019. PMID: 31392769. doi:10.1002/jum.15108
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。