临床图像中病灶检测的算法评估与视觉评估的相关性
本研究基于结直肠腺癌患者的前瞻性临床CT数据集,比较算法可检测性指数与放射科专家对肝转移灶检测及感知图像质量的排序一致性,发现两种评估强相关,提示可检测性指数能稳健反映临床CT条件下肝病灶检测的整体图像质量。
要点
- 算法可检测性指数与专家视觉评估对肝转移灶检测的排序高度一致。
- 病灶检测评估中95%患者排序相关系数分别超过0.87(Kendall's Tau)和0.94(Spearman's Rho)。
- 可检测性指数可定量反映不同成像条件对同一临床任务的信息质量。
核心结论
- 算法可检测性指数能预测观察者对肝转移灶检测和感知质量的评估。
- 可检测性指数稳健反映临床CT成像条件下肝病灶检测的整体图像质量。
- 该指标可用于定量评估不同成像条件为同一临床任务提供的信息内容质量。
研究设计与样本
- 基于机构审查委员会批准的前瞻性研究,纳入结直肠腺癌患者以检测肝转移。
- 同一患者同一屏气下采集标准剂量与低剂量CT系列,每个采集应用四种处理算法。
- 由专家放射科医生对感知图像质量和病灶检测性能进行评估与排序。
- 采用先前验证的方法计算各病灶尺寸及每个层面的可检测性指数,并结合肝病灶尺寸分布计算有效可检测性指数。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 病灶检测评估中,95%患者排序相关系数Kendall's Tau超过0.87、Spearman's Rho超过0.94(完全一致值为1)。
- 感知质量评估中,95%患者排序相关系数Kendall's Tau超过0.85、Spearman's Rho超过0.94(完全一致值为1)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 可检测性指数可作为临床CT肝病灶检测任务中图像质量的定量评估工具。
- 该指标有助于针对同一临床成像任务对不同成像条件进行靶向优化。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: Clinically-relevant quantitative measures of task-based image quality play key roles in effective optimization of medical imaging systems. Conventional phantom-based measures do not adequately reflect the real-world image quality of clinical Computed Tomography (CT) series which is most relevant for diagnostic decision-making. The assessment of detectability index which incorporates measurements of essential image quality metrics on patient CT images can overcome this limitation. Our current investigation extends and validates the technique on standard-of-care clinical cases.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: We obtained a clinical CT image dataset from an Institutional Review Board-approved prospective study on colorectal adenocarcinoma patients for detecting hepatic metastasis. For this study, both perceptual image quality and lesion detection performance of same-patient CT image series with standard and low dose acquisitions in the same breath hold and four processing algorithms applied to each acquisition were assessed and ranked by expert radiologists. The clinical CT image dataset was processed using the previously validated method to estimate a detectability index for each known lesion size in the size distribution of hepatic lesions relevant for the imaging task and for each slice of a CT series. We then combined these lesion-size-specific and slice-specific detectability indexes with the size distribution of hepatic lesions relevant for the imaging task to compute an effective detectability index for a clinical CT imaging condition of a patient. The assessed effective detectability indexes were used to rank task-based image quality of different imaging conditions on the same patient for all patients. We compared the assessments to those by expert radiologists in the prospective study in terms of rank order agreement between the rankings of algorithmic and visual assessment of lesion detection and perceptual quality.
RESULTS: Our investigation indicated that algorithmic assessment of lesion detection and perceptual quality can predict observer assessment for detecting hepatic metastasis. The algorithmic and visual assessment of lesion detection and perceptual quality are strongly correlated using both the Kendall's Tau and Spearman's Rho methods (perfect agreement has value 1): for assessment of lesion detection, 95% of the patients have rank correlation coefficients values exceeding 0.87 and 0.94, respectively, and for assessment of perceptual quality, 0.85 and 0.94, respectively.
CONCLUSION: This study used algorithmic detectability index to assess task-based image equality for detecting hepatic lesions and validated it against observer rankings on standard-of-care clinical CT cases. Our study indicates that detectability index provides a robust reflection of overall image quality for detecting hepatic lesions under clinical CT imaging conditions. This demonstrates the concept of utilizing the measure to quantitatively assess the quality of the information content that different imaging conditions can provide for the same clinical imaging task, which enables targeted optimization of clinical CT systems to minimize clinical and patient risks.
引用
- Cheng Y, Smith TB, Jensen CT, et al. Correlation of Algorithmic and Visual Assessment of Lesion Detection in Clinical Images. Acad Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31447259. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2019.07.015
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。