鼻咽癌影像分析与临床预测的放射组学工具比较
本研究纳入100例经活检证实的鼻咽癌病例,按T和N分期分层,比较Moddicom(v. 0.51)与Pyradiomics(v. 2.1.2)两个公开放射组学流程在头颈CT和MRI上提取特征的异质性。CT特征中76.1%(67个共同特征中51个)显著相关,MRI特征中28.6%(70个共同特征中20个)显著相关,形状特征在CT和MRI中均100%相关;这种流程间异质性影响了下游聚类与cTN状态和GTVp的关联,但形状特征在不同放射组学模块中是最可重复的临床参数预测因子。
要点
- CT放射组学特征在Moddicom与Pyradiomics间相关性高(76.1%),但MRI仅28.6%相关。
- 形状特征在CT和MRI中均100%可重复,是最稳健的临床参数预测因子。
- 流程间异质性影响放射组学特征与cTN状态和GTVp的下游聚类关联。
核心结论
- 两个公开放射组学流程间存在显著异质性,可能影响鼻咽癌放射组学特征与预后临床因素的下游关联;形状特征在不同模块中最可重复。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入100例经活检证实的鼻咽癌病例,按T和N分期分层;使用Moddicom(v. 0.51)和Pyradiomics(v. 2.1.2)两个放射组学流程提取CT和MRI特征;由三名放射肿瘤学家共识使用Velocity v. 4.0勾画原发肿瘤大体体积;采用Spearman秩相关分析两流程共同特征的组内相关性,并使用无监督层次聚类分析放射组学特征与临床参数的关联。
诊断标准与关键数值
- CT数据集中76.1%(67个共同特征中51个)在Moddicom与Pyradiomics间显著相关。
- MRI数据集中28.6%(70个共同特征中20个)在Moddicom与Pyradiomics间显著相关。
- 共同相关特征中,CT和MRI的形状相关特征均100%相关,一阶特征分别100%和23.5%相关,纹理特征分别61.9%和19.0%相关。
局限性
- 原文指出两个公开放射组学流程间存在显著异质性,可能影响下游与预后临床因素的关联。
- 原文强调在任何多中心影像数据集研究之前,有必要验证CT相关放射组学特征用于临床预后判断的稳定性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Radiomics pipelines have been developed to extract novel information from radiological images, which may help in phenotypic profiling of tumours that would correlate to prognosis. Here, we compared two publicly available pipelines for radiomics analyses on head and neck CT and MRI in nasopharynx cancer (NPC).
METHODS AND MATERIALS: 100 biopsy-proven NPC cases stratified by T- and N-categories were enrolled in this study. Two radiomics pipeline, Moddicom (v. 0.51) and Pyradiomics (v. 2.1.2) were used to extract radiomics features of CT and MRI. Segmentation of primary gross tumour volume was performed using Velocity v. 4.0 by consensus agreement between three radiation oncologists. Intraclass correlation between common features of the two pipelines was analysed by Spearman's rank correlation. Unsupervised hierarchical clustering was used to determine association between radiomics features and clinical parameters.
RESULTS: We observed a high proportion of correlated features in the CT data set, but not for MRI; 76.1% (51 of 67 common between Moddicom and Pyradiomics) of CT features and 28.6% (20 of 70 common) of MRI features were significantly correlated. Of these, 100% were shape-related for both CT and MRI, 100 and 23.5% were first-order-related, 61.9 and 19.0% were texture-related, respectively. This interpipeline heterogeneity affected the downstream clustering with known prognostic clinical parameters of cTN-status and GTVp. Nonetheless, shape features were the most reproducible predictors of clinical parameters among the different radiomics modules.
CONCLUSION: Here, we highlighted significant heterogeneity between two publicly available radiomics pipelines that could affect the downstream association with prognostic clinical factors in NPC.
ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE: The present study emphasized the broader importance of selecting stable radiomics features for disease phenotyping, and it is necessary prior to any investigation of multicentre imaging datasets to validate the stability of CT-related radiomics features for clinical prognostication.
引用
- Liang ZG, Tan HQ, Zhang F, et al. Comparison of radiomics tools for image analyses and clinical prediction in nasopharyngeal carcinoma. Br J Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31453720. doi:10.1259/bjr.20190271
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。