基于计算流体力学模拟的脑动脉瘤4D-DSA与3D-DSA定量与定性比较
本研究在10例脑动脉瘤患者中获取3D-DSA与4D-DSA数据集,并用计算流体力学比较两者的动脉瘤几何参数与血流动力学参数。4D-DSA的动脉瘤几何参数与3D-DSA高度相关,定性血流动力学参数完全一致,定量血流动力学参数几乎完全一致;尽管注射方案不同,4D-DSA仍是颅内血管计算流体力学分析的可靠基础,并提供与3D-DSA等同的动脉瘤几何可视化。
要点
- 4D-DSA与3D-DSA的动脉瘤几何参数高度相关(最大直径、瘤口尺寸、体积r均≥0.86)。
- 4D-DSA与3D-DSA的定性血流动力学参数(血流稳定性、复杂性、流入浓度)完全一致。
- 4D-DSA与3D-DSA的定量血流动力学参数几乎完全一致(r 0.84–1.00)。
核心结论
- 尽管注射方案不同,4D-DSA是颅内血管计算流体力学分析的可靠基础,并提供与3D-DSA等同的动脉瘤几何可视化。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入10例脑动脉瘤患者,获取3D-DSA与4D-DSA数据集,并对所有数据集进行计算流体力学分析。
- 以3D-DSA为当前标准,用计算流体力学比较4D-DSA与3D-DSA的动脉瘤几何参数与血流动力学参数。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 4D-DSA与3D-DSA的动脉瘤几何参数相关性:最大直径r=0.98(P<.001),瘤口尺寸OZ1/OZ2 r=0.98/0.86(P<.001/.002),体积r=0.98(P<.001)。
- 4D-DSA与3D-DSA的定量血流动力学参数相关性:舒张期平均/最大壁面剪切应力r=0.92/0.88(P<.001/.001),收缩期平均/最大壁面剪切应力r=0.94/0.93(P<.001/.001)。
- 4D-DSA与3D-DSA的定量血流动力学参数相关性:撞击区r=0.96(P<.001),低应力区r=1.00(P=.01),舒张期压力r=0.84(P=.002),收缩期压力r=0.9(P<.001)。
- 4D-DSA与3D-DSA的定量血流动力学参数相关性:舒张期血流速度r=0.95(P<.001),收缩期血流速度r=0.93(P<.001)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 4D-DSA可用于颅内血管计算流体力学分析,其动脉瘤几何可视化与3D-DSA等同。
- 4D-DSA与3D-DSA的定性血流动力学评估完全一致,定量参数几乎完全一致。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: 4D-DSA allows time-resolved 3D imaging of the cerebral vasculature. The aim of our study was to evaluate this method in comparison with the current criterion standard 3D-DSA by qualitative and quantitative means using computational fluid dynamics.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: 3D- and 4D-DSA datasets were acquired in patients with cerebral aneurysms. Computational fluid dynamics analysis was performed for all datasets. Using computational fluid dynamics, we compared 4D-DSA with 3D-DSA in terms of both aneurysmal geometry (quantitative: maximum diameter, ostium size [OZ1/2], volume) and hemodynamic parameters (qualitative: flow stability, flow complexity, inflow concentration; quantitative: average/maximum wall shear stress, impingement zone, low-stress zone, intra-aneurysmal pressure, and flow velocity). Qualitative parameters were descriptively analyzed. Correlation coefficients (r, P value) were calculated for quantitative parameters.
RESULTS: 3D- and 4D-DSA datasets of 10 cerebral aneurysms in 10 patients were postprocessed. Evaluation of aneurysmal geometry with 4D-DSA (r maximum diameter = 0.98, P maximum diameter <.001; r OZ1/OZ2 = 0.98/0.86, P OZ1/OZ2 < .001/.002; r volume = 0.98, P volume <.001) correlated highly with 3D-DSA. Evaluation of qualitative hemodynamic parameters (flow stability, flow complexity, inflow concentration) did show complete accordance, and evaluation of quantitative hemodynamic parameters (r average/maximum wall shear stress diastole = 0.92/0.88, P average/maximum wall shear stress diastole < .001/.001; r average/maximum wall shear stress systole = 0.94/0.93, P average/maximum wall shear stress systole < .001/.001; r impingement zone = 0.96, P impingement zone < .001; r low-stress zone = 1.00, P low-stress zone = .01; r pressure diastole = 0.84, P pressure diastole = .002; r pressure systole = 0.9, P pressure systole < .001; r flow velocity diastole = 0.95, P flow velocity diastole < .001; r flow velocity systole = 0.93, P flow velocity systole < .001) did show nearly complete accordance between 4D- and 3D-DSA.
CONCLUSIONS: Despite a different injection protocol, 4D-DSA is a reliable basis for computational fluid dynamics analysis of the intracranial vasculature and provides equivalent visualization of aneurysm geometry compared with 3D-DSA.
引用
- Lang S, Hoelter P, Birkhold AI, et al. Quantitative and Qualitative Comparison of 4D-DSA with 3D-DSA Using Computational Fluid Dynamics Simulations in Cerebral Aneurysms. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2019. PMID: 31467234. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A6172
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。