定量神经放射学倡议框架:在痴呆中的应用
提出定量神经放射学倡议(QNI)框架,用于将自动分割等图像定量软件转化为临床神经放射学工作流程。框架包含六个步骤:确定临床需求与影像生物标志物、开发自动分析方法、生成定量报告、技术及临床验证、整合入报告流程、使用中评估。以痴呆为例,指出现有视觉评定量表主观且粗泛,已有软件工具未在高通量或三级痴呆中心严格验证。
要点
- QNI框架用于将定量神经影像技术转化为临床报告流程
- 以痴呆为例,视觉评定量表主观、粗泛且存在地板和天花板效应
- 部分痴呆影像软件工具未在高通量或三级痴呆中心严格验证
核心结论
- QNI框架旨在解决定量神经影像技术临床转化中的验证与整合挑战,以满足对准确、及时、有影响力的临床影像服务日益增长的需求。
研究设计与样本
- 提出QNI模型框架,以当前痴呆放射学实践为例,描述六步转化路径,包括确定临床需求与影像生物标志物、开发自动分析方法、生成定量报告、技术及临床验证、整合入临床报告流程和使用中评估。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 定量分析可提供结合常模数据的临床相关指标,支持报告者工作
- 定量分析可提高纵向比较的精确度
- 定量分析可生成不同经验水平放射科医生间更一致的报告
局限性
- 视觉评定量表具有一定主观性且为粗泛分类器,存在地板和天花板效应
- 一些临床获批的放射学软件工具总体上未在高通量或三级痴呆中心经过严格临床验证
- 定量技术向临床环境转化面临显著挑战
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
There are numerous challenges to identifying, developing and implementing quantitative techniques for use in clinical radiology, suggesting the need for a common translational pathway. We developed the quantitative neuroradiology initiative (QNI), as a model framework for the technical and clinical validation necessary to embed automated segmentation and other image quantification software into the clinical neuroradiology workflow. We hypothesize that quantification will support reporters with clinically relevant measures contextualized with normative data, increase the precision of longitudinal comparisons, and generate more consistent reporting across levels of radiologists' experience. The QNI framework comprises the following steps: (1) establishing an area of clinical need and identifying the appropriate proven imaging biomarker(s) for the disease in question; (2) developing a method for automated analysis of these biomarkers, by designing an algorithm and compiling reference data; (3) communicating the results via an intuitive and accessible quantitative report; (4) technically and clinically validating the proposed tool pre-use; (5) integrating the developed analysis pipeline into the clinical reporting workflow; and (6) performing in-use evaluation. We will use current radiology practice in dementia as an example, where radiologists have established visual rating scales to describe the degree and pattern of atrophy they detect. These can be helpful, but are somewhat subjective and coarse classifiers, suffering from floor and ceiling limitations. Meanwhile, several imaging biomarkers relevant to dementia diagnosis and management have been proposed in the literature; some clinically approved radiology software tools exist but in general, these have not undergone rigorous clinical validation in high volume or in tertiary dementia centres. The QNI framework aims to address this need. Quantitative image analysis is developing apace within the research domain. Translating quantitative techniques into the clinical setting presents significant challenges, which must be addressed to meet the increasing demand for accurate, timely and impactful clinical imaging services.
引用
- Goodkin O, Pemberton H, Vos SB, et al. The quantitative neuroradiology initiative framework: application to dementia. Br J Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31368776. doi:10.1259/bjr.20190365
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。