介入放射科医生执业模式的性别差异
基于美国Medicare理赔数据识别2936名介入放射科医生(IR),女性仅占8.2%(241/2936),地域与职业阶段分布不均。男女IR在介入病例构成、操作复杂度和患者复杂度上相似,但女性IR用于侵入性服务和非侵入性诊断影像的工作量比例略低,而评估与管理门诊比例更高(14.5% vs 7.9%)。
要点
- 女性IR仅占8.2%(241/2936),九個州≤2%,三个州≥20%。
- 男女IR介入病例构成与操作复杂度相似,高复杂度操作女性59.5% vs 男性61.3%。
- 女性IR评估与管理门诊占比14.5%,高于男性IR的7.9%。
核心结论
- 女性在介入放射学中仍代表性不足,但女性IR的介入病例构成、操作复杂度和患者复杂度与男性同事相似;女性IR更高的评估与管理门诊比例支持该专业对纵向护理的日益关注。
研究设计与样本
- 基于Medicare理赔数据,依据计费临床工作量的分布识别IR,并按性别描述性刻画执业模式,共识别全国2936名IR。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 女性占全部IR的8.2%(241/2936)。
- 女性代表性在地域上≤2%的有九个州,≥20%的有三个州。
- 按职业阶段:早期职业IR中女性占9.4%,晚期职业IR中占6.4%;东北部早期职业IR中女性占18.8%。
- 低复杂度操作占比:女性IR 5.7% vs 男性IR 4.3%;高复杂度操作占比:女性IR 59.5% vs 男性IR 61.3%。
- 平均患者复杂度评分:女性IR 2.7 ± 12(SD) vs 男性IR 2.8 ± 12。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 女性IR用于侵入性服务的工作量比例为66.5%,男性IR为70.0%。
- 女性IR用于非侵入性诊断影像的工作量比例为19.0%,男性IR为22.2%。
- 女性IR用于评估与管理门诊的工作量比例为14.5%,男性IR为7.9%。
- 女性IR和男性IR均将多数服务提供给女性患者(53.4% vs 53.1%)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE. Given recent specialty attention to workforce diversity, we aimed to characterize potential gender differences in the practice patterns of interventional radiologists (IRs). MATERIALS AND METHODS. Using Medicare claims data, we identified IRs on the basis of the distribution of their billed clinical work effort and descriptively characterized practice patterns by gender. RESULTS. Women represented 8.2% (241/2936) of all IRs identified nationally. Female representation varied geographically (≤ 2% in nine states, ≥ 20% in three states) and by career stage (9.4% among early-career IRs and 6.4% among late-career IRs; 18.8% among early-career IRs in the Northeast). For both female IRs and male IRs, interventional case mixes were similar across service categories (e.g., venous and hemodialysis access, arterial and venous interventions, biopsies and drainages) and by procedural complexity (e.g., 5.7% vs 4.3% for low-complexity procedures and 59.5% vs 61.3% for high-complexity procedures). Average patient complexity scores were also similar for female (2.7 ± 12 [SD]) and male (2.8 ± 12) IRs. Female IRs spent slightly lower portions of their work effort rendering invasive services (66.5% vs 70.0%, respectively) and noninvasive diagnostic imaging (19.0% vs 22.2%) than male IRs but spent more time in evaluation and management clinical visits (14.5% vs 7.9%). Both female IRs and male IRs rendered a majority of their services to female patients (53.4% vs 53.1%). CONCLUSION. Although women remain underrepresented in interventional radiology, female IRs' interventional case composition, procedural complexity, and patient complexity are similar to those of their male colleagues. Female IRs' higher proportion of evaluation and management clinical visits supports the specialty's increased focus on longitudinal care so that interventional radiology will thrive alongside other clinical specialties.
引用
- Rosenkrantz AB, Englander MJ, Deipolyi AR, et al. Clinical Practice Patterns of Interventional Radiologists by Gender. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2019. PMID: 31268735. doi:10.2214/AJR.19.21321
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。