在相位对比电影MRI定量脊髓脑脊液搏动时,心电门控比外周脉搏门控更精确
本研究在10名健康志愿者中于3T行二维相位对比电影MRI,比较回顾性心电门控与外周脉搏门控对颈、胸、腰段脑脊液搏动流量的测量准确性;心电门控的定量与时间统计变异更小,均方根误差在C1、C4、T1、T7、L2均低于脉搏门控,但脉搏门控数据在至少5名受试者队列平均时与心电门控数据相关性良好。
要点
- 心电门控相位对比电影MRI较外周脉搏门控在脑脊液流量分析中定量与时间精度更高。
- 心电门控脑脊液瞬时流量呈一致的头尾方向递减,脉搏门控结果一致性较差。
- 脉搏门控脑脊液流量结果在至少5名受试者队列平均时合理,但细微结论需谨慎解释。
核心结论
- 心电门控相位对比电影MRI在脑脊液定量流量分析中比外周脉搏门控在定量和时间上更精确。
研究设计与样本
- 研究扫描10名健康志愿者(年龄23-46岁),在3T行回顾性心电门控或回顾性外周脉搏门控的二维相位对比电影MRI,扫描层面为C1、C4、T1、T7、L1-L3,数据用基于Matlab的自定义软件分析。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 心电门控相位对比电影MRI的均方根误差值在C1、C4、T1、T7、L2分别为6.04、6.94、4.81、4.49、4.16,外周脉搏门控分别为7.24、8.97、7.9、7.82、6.68。
- 以心电门控相位对比电影MRI为参考标准,外周脉搏门控数据在至少5名受试者队列平均时与之相关性良好。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 心电门控相位对比电影MRI在脑脊液定量流量分析中定量与时间统计变异小于外周脉搏门控。
- 外周脉搏门控脑脊液流量结果在至少5名受试者队列平均时合理,但细微结论应谨慎解释。
局限性
- 外周脉搏门控脑脊液流量结果仅在至少5名受试者队列平均时合理,细微结论应谨慎解释。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To compare accuracy of spinal cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) pulsatile flow measurements at cervical, thoracic, and lumbar levels using Phase Contrast Cine MRI (PCCMRI) with retrospective electrocardiogram (recg) vs. retrospective peripheral pulse gating (rppg) gating.
METHODS: We scanned 10 healthy volunteers, ages 23-46 years, using external recg-gated or rppg-gated 2D PCCCMRI at 3T. Transverse scans of CSF, arteries and veins scans were at C1/C4/T1/T7/L1-L3. Data were analyzed with custom Matlab-based software, measuring CSF, arterial (descending aorta, abdominal aorta, common carotid artery, ICA, and vertebral artery) and venous (internal jugular vein and inferior vena cava) flow, velocity and region of interest area.
RESULTS: recgPCCMRI produced less quantitative and temporal statistical variation than pcgPCCMRI when analyzing CSF flow. The instantaneous recgPCCMRI CSF flows consistently decreased craniocaudally, while the results with rppgPCCMRI were less consistent. The recgPCCMRI root mean square error values were 6.04, 6.94, 4.81, 4.49, and 4.16 for C1, C4, T1, T7, and L2, compared with 7.24, 8.97, 7.9, 7.82, and 6.68 for rppgPCCMRI. Results were independent of analysts. Summations of standard errors produced similar results. RppgPCCMRI also showed increase variability of CSF flow correlations with arteries and veins compared to recgPCCMRI. None-the-less, when recgPCCMRI is considered the reference standard, there is good correlations between rppgPCCMRI and recgPCCMRIdata sets, when averaged over cohorts of at least five subjects.
CONCLUSION: Our results indicated that recgPCCMRI is more quantitatively and temporally precise than rppgPCCMRI in CSF quantitative flow analysis. Pulse-gating CSF flow results are reasonable when averaged over cohorts of at least five subjects, but subtle conclusions should be interpreted with caution.
引用
- Bert RJ, Settipalle N, Muddasani D, et al. ECG Gating Is More Precise Than Peripheral Pulse Gating When Quantifying Spinal CSF Pulsations Using Phase Contrast Cine MRI. Acad Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31353089. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2019.06.015
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。