儿科急诊医学培训共识核心床旁超声应用
儿科急诊医学床旁超声网络(P2Network)采用改良德尔菲法,由48名符合专家标准的专家对60项床旁超声应用进行两轮评分,最终达成共识纳入21项核心应用、排除7项,其余39项未达成纳入或排除共识。
要点
- 专家共识确定21项核心床旁超声应用应纳入儿科急诊医学专科培训课程。
- 另有7项应用被共识排除,39项应用未达成纳入或排除共识。
- 第一轮48名专家完成调查,第二轮37名专家完成,共识基于改良德尔菲法。
核心结论
- 专家就21项核心床旁超声应用达成共识,应纳入儿科急诊医学专科培训课程。
研究设计与样本
- 改良德尔菲共识构建法;从P2Network及更广泛儿科急诊床旁超声社区招募多国专家,专家标准为完成超过1000次床旁超声扫查且至少3年儿科急诊医学专科培训学员床旁超声教学经验、为当地学术床旁超声领导者或完成正式儿科急诊床旁超声专科培训;第一轮48名专家完成调查,第二轮37名专家完成。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 专家对60项可能的儿科急诊床旁超声应用按纳入专科培训课程的重要性进行评分。
- 第一轮共识纳入18项、排除2项;第二轮共识再纳入3项、排除5项;两轮合计纳入21项、排除7项。
- 其余39项应用未达成纳入或排除共识。
局限性
- 第二轮仅37名专家完成,未达成共识的39项应用未被纳入或排除。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Pediatric emergency medicine (PEM) physicians have variably incorporated point-of-care ultrasound (POCUS) into their practice. Prior guidelines describe the scope of POCUS practice for PEM physicians; however, consensus does not yet exist about which applications should be prioritized and taught as fundamental skills for PEM trainees. Members of the PEM POCUS Network (P2Network) conducted a consensus-building process to determine which applications to incorporate into PEM fellowship training.
METHODS: A multinational group of experts in PEM POCUS was recruited from the P2Network and greater PEM POCUS community if they met the following criteria: performed over 1,000 POCUS scans and had at least 3 years of experience teaching POCUS to PEM fellows, were a local academic POCUS leader, or completed a formal PEM POCUS fellowship. Experts rated 60 possible PEM POCUS applications for their importance to include as part of a PEM fellowship curriculum using a modified Delphi consensus-building technique.
RESULTS: In round 1, 66 of 92 (72%) participants responded to an e-mail survey of which 48 met expert criteria and completed the survey. Consensus was reached to include 18 items in a PEM fellowship curriculum and to exclude two items. The 40 remaining items and seven additional items were considered in round 2. Thirty-seven of 48 (77%) experts completed round 2 reaching consensus to include three more items and exclude five. The remaining 39 items did not reach consensus for inclusion or exclusion.
CONCLUSION: Experts reached consensus on 21 core POCUS applications to include in PEM fellowship curricula.
引用
- Shefrin AE, Warkentine F, Constantine E, et al. Consensus Core Point-of-care Ultrasound Applications for Pediatric Emergency Medicine Training. AEM Educ Train. 2019. PMID: 31360818. doi:10.1002/aet2.10332
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。