功能MRI定量成像鉴别人类软骨退变——一项离体研究
离体研究对59个膝关节置换患者的大体完整骨软骨样本行T1、T2、T2*和T1ρ定量成像,在压痕加载至405 μm和810 μm前后比较参数变化,并按Mankin评分分为完整组(0-4分,n=35)与早期退变组(5-8分,n=24);早期退变组T1ρ加载后相对升高显著大于完整组,T1、T2、T2*未见显著退变相关变化。
要点
- T1ρ在加载后升高,早期退变组升高幅度显著大于完整组,差异以软骨下 pistonal 区最明显。
- T1、T2、T2*在加载后未见与退变程度相关的显著变化。
- 功能MRI的T1ρ加载响应可在离体条件下可靠识别早期退变软骨。
核心结论
- 早期退变软骨的异常承载反应可通过T1ρ定量成像随加载的变化检出,从而在离体条件下鉴别完整与早期退变软骨。
研究设计与样本
- 离体研究,经IRB批准并获书面知情同意,取自全膝关节置换患者股骨外侧髁中央的59个大体完整骨软骨样本。
- 在位移控制准静态压痕加载至405 μm(Δ1/2)和810 μm(Δ1)前及加载中生成空间分辨的T1、T2、T2*和T1ρ图。
- 手动分割后计算整个样本及不同区域带的绝对qMRI参数和加载诱导相对变化(δ1/2、δ1)。
- 以组织学Mankin总分(MSS,范围0-14)为参考,将样本二分为完整组(MSS 0-4,n=35)和早期退变组(MSS 5-8,n=24)。
关键影像表现/征象
- T1ρ在加载后于δ1/2和δ1均呈一致性升高。
- 整个样本T1ρ升高幅度早期退变组大于完整组,区域和分区分析显示该变化在软骨下 pistonal 区最明显。
- T1、T2、T2*未见与退变程度相关的显著加载诱导变化。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 以组织学Mankin总分(MSS,0-14)为参考标准,完整组MSS 0-4、早期退变组MSS 5-8。
- T1ρ加载诱导相对变化δ1/2:早期退变组23.8%(q25=18.1%,q75=29.0%)vs 完整组12.7%(q25=5.9%,q75=19.5%),p<0.0005(Wilcoxon符号秩检验)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 解读T1ρ时应关注加载前后的相对变化,而不仅是静息绝对值。
- 报告分区结果时注意软骨下 pistonal 区对退变相关加载响应最敏感。
- T1、T2、T2*在加载条件下未见退变相关显著变化,不宜据此判断早期退变。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate whether the response to loading of cartilage samples as assessed ex vivo by quantitative MRI (qMRI) mapping techniques can differentiate intact and early degenerative cartilage.
METHODS: Upon IRB approval and written informed consent, 59 macroscopically intact osteochondral samples were obtained from the central lateral femoral condyles of patients undergoing total knee replacement. Spatially resolved T1, T2, T2*, and T1ρ maps were generated prior to and during displacement-controlled quasi-static indentation loading to 405 μm (Δ1/2) and 810 μm (Δ1). Upon manual segmentation, absolute qMRI parameters and loading-induced relative changes (δ1/2, δ1) were determined for the entire cartilage sample and distinct zones and regions. Based on their histologically determined degeneration as quantified according to Mankin (Mankin sum scores [MSS], range 0-14), samples were dichotomised into intact (int; MSS 0-4, n = 35) and early degenerative (ed, MSS 5-8, n = 24).
RESULTS: For T1ρ, consistent loading-induced increases were found for δ1/2 and δ1. Throughout the entire sample, increases in T1ρ were significantly higher in early degenerative than in intact samples (Δ1/2(ed) = 23.8 [q25 = 18.1, q75 = 29.0] %; Δ1/2(int) = 12.7 [q25 = 5.9, q75 = 19.5] %; p < 0.0005), according to Wilcoxon's signed-rank test). Zonal and regional analysis revealed these changes to be most pronounced in the sub-pistonal area. No significant degeneration-dependent loading-induced changes were found for T1, T2, or T2*.
CONCLUSION: Aberrant load-bearing of early degenerative cartilage may be detected using T1ρ mapping as a function of loading. Hence, the diagnostic differentiation of intact versus early degenerative cartilage may allow the reliable identification of early and potentially reversible cartilage degeneration, thereby opening new opportunities for diagnosis and treatment of cartilage pathologies.
KEY POINTS: • T1ρ mapping of the cartilage response to loading allows the reliable identification of early degenerative changes ex vivo. • Distinct response-to-loading patterns of cartilage tissue as assessed by functional MRI techniques are associated with biomechanical and histological tissue properties. • Non-invasive functional MR imaging techniques may facilitate the more sensitive monitoring of therapeutic outcomes and treatment strategies.
引用
- Truhn D, Sondern B, Oehrl S, et al. Differentiation of human cartilage degeneration by functional MRI mapping-an ex vivo study. Eur Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31187218. doi:10.1007/s00330-019-06283-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。