补充培训提升放射科医生乳腺癌筛查表现的效用:文献综述
该系统综述于2017年8月3日检索PubMed,纳入18篇描述放射科医生阅读乳腺X线片补充培训的研究,其中17篇显示至少一项结局指标改善。研究质量多为中等(医学教育研究质量工具评分11.7±1.7),主要因样本量小和缺乏对照组。作者结论:补充培训有助于提升筛查表现,但需设计更好的研究,未来应关注真实筛查实践并设法分离培训效应。
要点
- 补充培训在至少一项结局指标上改善放射科医生乳腺筛查表现,17/18篇研究显示改善。
- 测试集测量中最常报告敏感度和特异度(8/11篇),真实筛查实践中最常报告召回率(6/7篇)。
- 纳入研究质量多为中等(医学教育研究质量工具评分11.7±1.7),主要因样本量小和缺乏对照组。
核心结论
- 补充培训有助于放射科医生改善乳腺筛查表现,尽管纳入研究质量主要为中等。
- 需要设计更好的研究,未来研究应关注真实筛查实践中的表现,并寻找分离培训效应的方法。
- 若使用测试集,应关注测试集表现与真实筛查实践之间相关性的知识。
研究设计与样本
- 文献综述:于2017年8月3日在PubMed进行系统检索,纳入描述放射科医生阅读乳腺X线片补充培训且至少报告一项结局指标的研究。
- 共识别2199篇文章,最终纳入18篇;使用医学教育研究质量工具(Medical Education Research Study Quality Instrument)评估研究质量。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 测试集测量方法:敏感度和特异度是最常报告的结局指标(8/11项研究)。
- 真实筛查实践测量方法:召回率是最常报告的结局指标(6/7项研究)。
- 研究质量评分:医学教育研究质量工具评分为11.7±1.7。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为补充培训有助于改善乳腺筛查表现,未来研究应关注真实筛查实践中的表现并设法分离培训效应。
- 作者建议若使用测试集,应关注测试集表现与真实筛查实践之间相关性的知识。
局限性
- 研究质量主要为中等(医学教育研究质量工具评分11.7±1.7),原因为样本量小和缺乏对照组。
- 需要设计更好的研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: The authors evaluate whether supplemental training for radiologists improves their breast screening performance and how this is measured.
METHODS: A systematic search was conducted in PubMed on August 3, 2017. Articles were included if they described supplemental training for radiologists reading mammograms to improve their breast screening performance and at least one outcome measure was reported. Study quality was assessed using the Medical Education Research Study Quality Instrument.
RESULTS: Of 2,199 identified articles, 18 were included, of which 17 showed improvement on at least one of the outcome measures, for at least one training activity or subgroup. Two measurement approaches were found. For the first approach, measuring performance on test sets, sensitivity, and specificity were the most reported outcomes (8 of 11 studies). Recall rate is the most reported outcome (6 of 7 studies) for the second approach, which measures performance in actual screening practice. The studies were mainly of moderate quality (Medical Education Research Study Quality Instrument score 11.7 ± 1.7), caused by small sample sizes and the lack of a control group.
CONCLUSIONS: Supplemental training helps radiologists improve their screening performance, despite the mainly moderate quality of the studies. There is a need for better designed studies. Future studies should focus on performance in actual screening practice and should look for methods to isolate the training effect. If test sets are used, focus should be on knowledge about correlation between performance on test sets and actual screening practice.
引用
- Geertse TD, Paap E, van der Waal D, et al. Utility of Supplemental Training to Improve Radiologist Performance in Breast Cancer Screening: A Literature Review. J Am Coll Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31247156. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2019.04.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。