以全标本组织病理学为参考标准比较PI-RADS v1与v2在多参数MRI检测前列腺癌中的表现
回顾性分析40例经直肠超声引导活检阳性患者的前列腺切除术前3 T多参数MRI,由两名阅片者分别按PI-RADS v1和v2评估可疑病灶,以全标本切片为参考标准。v2的敏感度呈低于v1的趋势但差异无统计学意义,作者认为v2的简化分区方案未必优于v1。
要点
- v2敏感度呈低于v1趋势但未达统计学显著(R1 72.4% vs 63.8%,P=0.426;R2 77.6% vs 69.0%,P=0.402)。
- 移行区及低级别癌中该趋势更明显,但差异仍无统计学意义(P值0.313–0.691)。
- 两名阅片者PI-RADS v1与v2的κ值均为0.48,v1最高评分与v2主导序列一致率R1 48%、R2 53%。
核心结论
- 作者认为PI-RADS v2(2015)的简化分区评估方法未必优于原v1标准(2012),特定病例中严格按v2判读甚至可能导致假阴性。
- 作者提出应重新审视现行PI-RADS标准,尽管本研究的统计学证据有限。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析40例经直肠超声引导活检阳性患者的前列腺切除术前3 T多参数MRI(T2w、DWI、DCE),由两名分别为5年和4年经验的盲法阅片者按PI-RADS v1和v2评估。
- 参考标准为前列腺切除标本的全标本切片。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 按病灶计算的敏感度:R1为v1 72.4% vs v2 63.8%(P=0.426),R2为v1 77.6% vs v2 69.0%(P=0.402)。
- 按病灶计算的PPV差异总体及各分区均无统计学意义。
- v1最高评分与v2主导序列(DWI或T2w)的一致率R1为48%、R2为53%;两名阅片者间PI-RADS v1与v2的κ值均为0.48。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为PI-RADS v2的简化分区方法未必优于v1,特定病例中严格按v2判读可能导致假阴性。
- 作者提出应重新审视现行PI-RADS标准,尽管本研究统计学证据有限。
局限性
- 原文在结论中自述本研究的统计学证据有限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to compare Prostate Imaging Reporting and Data System (PI-RADS) versions v1 and v2 for the detection of prostate cancer (PCa) in multiparametric MRI (mpMRI) using whole-mount histological workup as reference standard.
MATERIAL AND METHODS: MRI data of 40 patients with positive transrectal ultrasound-guided biopsy were analyzed retrospectively by two blinded readers (5 and 4 years' experience) with PI-RADS v1 and v2 for cancer-suspicious lesions. Prior to radical prostatectomy, patients had undergone IRB-approved mpMRI at 3 T according to PI-RADS recommendations: T2-weighted (T2w), diffusion-weighted (DWI) and dynamic contrast-enhanced (DCE) imaging. The reference standard was provided by whole-mount sections of the prostatectomy specimens. Versions v1 and v2 were compared with respect to sensitivity and positive predictive value (PPV) per lesion. Subgroups stratified by tumor location (peripheral vs. transition zone) and aggressiveness (high vs. low grade) were also analyzed. We also evaluated the concordance of the dominant MRI sequence in v2 (DWI or T2w) and the highest individual score under v1. Interobserver agreement for PI-RADS v1 and v2 was assessed by Cohen's kappa statistics.
RESULTS: Reader 1 (R1) described 66 and Reader 2 (R2) 72 MRI lesions. The average Gleason score of 58 PCa lesions was 6.5 (range: 6 = 3 + 3 to 8 = 4 + 4), most of them (65.5%) located in the peripheral zone. PI-RADS v2 showed a trend towards lower sensitivities, but differences were not significant for both readers: R1 72.4% (v1) vs. 63.8% (v2) (P = 0.426) and R2 77.6% (v1) vs. 69.0% (v2) (P = 0.402). The trends were more pronounced in the transition zone and for low-grade cancers but remained insignificant (p-values from 0.313 to 0.691). Likewise, the apparent PPV differences, overall as well as in each zone, were not significant. Agreement between high-score v1 and dominant v2 sequence was 48% for R1 and 53% for R2. Cohen's κ of PCa detection for two readers was 0.48 for both v1 and v2.
CONCLUSION: Our findings indicate that the simplified, zone-specific approach of PI-RADS v2 (2015) for MRI assessment of prostate cancer may not necessarily be better than the original v1 criteria (2012). In specific cases, a strict interpretation of v2 criteria may even lead to false-negative findings. Therefore, the current PI-RADS criteria should be reconsidered, despite the low statistical evidence here.
引用
- Schaudinn A, Gawlitza J, Mucha S, et al. Comparison of PI-RADS v1 and v2 for multiparametric MRI detection of prostate cancer with whole-mount histological workup as reference standard. Eur J Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31153562. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2019.04.012
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。