计算机辅助器械导航与传统C臂透视在外科器械置入中的比较:准确性、辐射时间与辐射暴露
研究在尸体上比较超低辐射成像联合图像增强与器械追踪(ULRI-IE/IT)与传统透视辅助器械置入的准确性与辐射输出。23例次9种操作中,使用ULRI-IE/IT使总定位时间延长31.2%,但每例图像数减少74.8%、辐射暴露减少91.8%,82.6%的试验首次尝试即准确置入,全部试验第二次尝试成功,而传统透视平均需4.65张图像。
要点
- ULRI-IE/IT使每例图像数减少74.8%、辐射暴露减少91.8%。
- 使用ULRI-IE/IT时总定位时间较无辅助延长31.2%。
- ULRI-IE/IT首次尝试准确置入率82.6%,全部第二次尝试成功。
核心结论
- 使用ULRI-IE/IT可大幅减少辐射输出、采集图像数及透视操作所需时间。
研究设计与样本
- 尸体研究,5名不同专科医师在9种脊柱、骨科、疼痛及理疗操作中完成23例次配对试验(有和无ULRI-IE/IT辅助),随机分配是否使用ULRI-IE/IT以减少学习效应,记录辐射暴露、置入时间及所需图像数。
诊断标准与关键数值
- ULRI-IE/IT辅助下首次尝试准确置入率为82.6%,第二次尝试全部成功;无辅助透视平均需4.65张图像。
- 全部23例总定位时间无辅助时较有辅助延长31.2%。
- ULRI-IE/IT使每例图像总数减少74.8%,辐射暴露减少91.8%。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE. Compared with open procedures, minimally invasive surgical procedures are associated with increased radiation exposure and long-term health risks. Ultralow radiation imaging coupled with image enhancement and instrument tracking (ULRI-IE/IT) is a new image modifier that allows a computer to show real-time movement of an instrument as it is adjusted, mimicking live fluoroscopy but without continuous radiation production. The purpose of this study was to determine the accuracy and radiation output of ULRI-IE/IT compared with unassisted conventional fluoroscopy in a variety of surgical procedures. MATERIALS AND METHODS. Physicians of various specialties were asked to identify the ideal location for instrumentation in various spinal, orthopedic, pain, and physiatric procedures and then place an instrument in this location in a cadaver both with and without ULRI-IE/IT assistance. Whether ULRI-IE/IT was used was randomly assigned to reduce the impact of learning. Radiation exposure, time to place the instrument, and the number of images required to achieve accurate positioning were recorded for each procedure. These were compared for unassisted and ULRI-IE/IT-assisted fluoroscopy to determine the utility of ULRI-IE/IT in minimally invasive instrumentation. RESULTS. Twenty-three trials of nine procedures by five physicians were completed both with and without assistance of ULRI-IE/IT. The procedures ranged from percutaneous pedicle screw insertion to foramen ovale ablation. Total time to localize the instrument for all 23 cases was 31.2% longer without assistance. Use of ULRI-IE/IT reduced the total number of images per case by 74.8% and radiation exposure by 91.8%. With ULRI-IE/IT, physicians were able to successfully place the instrument in the correct location on the first attempt in 82.6% of trials and in the second attempt in all trials versus a mean of 4.65 images needed for unassisted fluoroscopy. CONCLUSION. Use of ULRI-IE/IT can dramatically reduce radiation output and the number of images acquired and time required to perform fluoroscopic procedures.
引用
- Wang TY, Hamouda F, Sankey EW, et al. Computer-Assisted Instrument Navigation Versus Conventional C-Arm Fluoroscopy for Surgical Instrumentation: Accuracy, Radiation Time, and Radiation Exposure. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2019. PMID: 31063421. doi:10.2214/AJR.18.20788
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。