大型教学医学中心骨关节炎随访中减少不必要的重复膝关节X线检查
该质量改进项目在大型教学医学中心回顾了膝X线报告,基线500例中22%为重复检查、15%无指征;对骨科和家庭医学部门进行针对性教育干预后,500例中重复检查降至10%、无指征降至8%,且1年时该降低得以维持。结论为针对性教育干预可使已知重度骨关节炎患者中不必要的重复膝X线检查数量大幅减少(50%)。
要点
- 已知重度骨关节炎随访中,无新发症状时的重复膝X线检查属无指征检查。
- 基线500例中重复膝X线112/500(22%),无指征77/500(15%)。
- 教育干预后500例中重复膝X线降至52/500(10%),无指征降至40/500(8%)。
核心结论
- 针对性教育干预使已知重度骨关节炎患者中不必要的重复膝X线检查数量大幅减少(50%),且该降低在1年时得以维持。
研究设计与样本
- 质量改进项目,免于IRB审查;通过数据库检索含「severe」「degenerative」「osteoarthritis」及类似变体的膝X线报告,基线审阅500份连续病历确认重度骨关节炎及6个月内重复X线,干预后9个月及1年时点各审阅500份报告。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 重复X线适应症依据病历确定,病历无新发症状时计为「无指征」。
- 基线500例中重复膝X线112/500(22%),无指征77/500(15%)。
- 干预后9个月500例中重复膝X线52/500(10%),无指征40/500(8%)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 专业组织建议反对骨关节炎常规随访时重复X线检查。
- 病历无新发症状时,重复膝X线可判定为无指征检查。
- 针对性教育干预可减少不必要的重复膝X线检查并维持1年。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Professional organizations recommend against repeat radiographs for routine follow-up of osteoarthrosis. However, clinics frequently obtain radiographs during or before the clinical visit. The purpose of our project was to determine the baseline frequency of unnecessary knee radiographs and whether educational interventions can reduce this frequency.
METHODS: This QI project was exempt from IRB review. Radiology reports of knee radiographs were searched in our database filtered by presence of the words "severe", "degenerative", "osteoarthritis", and similar variants. We reviewed 500 consecutive corresponding medical records to confirm the presence of severe osteoarthritis, and presence of a repeat radiograph within 6 months. Indications for repeat radiographs were determined. Repeat radiographs were counted as "non-indicated" when medical records revealed no new symptoms. A focused educational intervention was provided to the orthopedic and family practice departments. An additional 500 radiology reports were evaluated 9 months after intervention in the same manner and the rate of non-indicated radiographs was calculated. Follow-up review of additional 500 radiology reports at 1-year time point was performed.
RESULTS: Our initial search returned 1517 reports. Upon evaluation of 500 studies, there were 112/500 repeat radiographs (22%); 77/500 (15%) of knee radiographs were not indicated. Upon initial follow-up evaluation of 500 studies, there were 52/500 repeat radiographs (10%) and 40/500 (8%) radiographs were not indicated. The reduction of unnecessary repeat knee radiographs rate was sustained at 1 year.
CONCLUSIONS: Focused educational intervention results in a substantial (50%) reduction of the number of unnecessary repeat knee radiographs in patients with known severe OA.
引用
- Ashikyan O, Buller DC, Pezeshk P, et al. Reduction of unnecessary repeat knee radiographs during osteoarthrosis follow-up visits in a large teaching medical center. Skeletal Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31139920. doi:10.1007/s00256-019-03247-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。