三维能量多普勒超声联合VOCAL在乳腺肿块血管分布中的诊断价值
本研究纳入322个经手术且有明确病理诊断的乳腺实性病灶(良性262例、恶性60例),用GE LOGIQ E9及VOCAL软件计算体积和灰阶均值、能量均值、比值、血管血流指数四项血管指标,并与BI-RADS评分联合评估。结果显示恶性组年龄和能量均值大于良性组(P<.01),比值、血管血流指数、体积差异有统计学意义(P<.01);能量均值联合BI-RADS的AUC最高(0.928)。作者认为三维能量多普勒超声联合VOCAL定量测量血流及血管分布较传统二维超声更准确、更敏感。
要点
- 能量均值+BI-RADS的AUC为0.928,高于单纯BI-RADS的0.796。
- 年龄、能量均值、比值、血管血流指数、体积的AUC分别为0.864、0.830、0.800、0.758、0.764。
- 对应截断值分别为37.5、26.56、0.031、0.846、1.75,敏感度93.3%、75%、81.7%、68.3%、63.3%。
核心结论
- 三维能量多普勒超声联合VOCAL法定量测量乳腺肿瘤血流及血管分布,较传统二维超声更准确、更敏感,作者认为在肿瘤血管随机分布研究或肿瘤血管正常化研究等领域有潜在应用前景,并为乳腺癌疗效评估提供新途径。
研究设计与样本
- 收集322个经手术且有明确病理诊断的实性病灶,其中良性病灶262例、恶性病灶60例;所有检查使用GE LOGIQ E9及VOCAL软件,计算体积及灰阶均值(MG)、能量均值、比值(R)、血管血流指数(VFI)四项血管指标,采样和计算重复三次取均值。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 年龄、能量均值、比值、血管血流指数、体积的AUC分别为0.864、0.830、0.800、0.758、0.764,均高于50%曲线,显示诊断价值。
- 年龄、能量均值、比值、血管血流指数、体积的截断值分别为37.5、26.56、0.031、0.846、1.75,对应敏感度分别为93.3%、75%、81.7%、68.3%、63.3%,特异度分别为68.7%、81%、70.2%、75.6%、81.7%。
- 能量均值+BI-RADS、比值+BI-RADS、VFI+BI-RADS及单纯BI-RADS的AUC分别为0.928、0.903、0.895、0.796,均高于50%曲线。
- 上述四种方法的敏感度分别为81.7%、80%、88.3%、86.7%,特异度分别为88.5%、85.5%、77.1%、69.5%。
- 能量均值+BI-RADS法在三种联合方法中AUC最高。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 恶性组年龄和能量均值大于良性组(P<.01),灰阶均值低于良性组但差异无统计学意义(P>.05),比值、血管血流指数和体积差异有统计学意义(P<.01)。
- 能量均值+BI-RADS、比值+BI-RADS、VFI+BI-RADS的AUC分别为0.928、0.903、0.895,均高于单纯BI-RADS的0.796。
- 作者认为三维能量多普勒超声联合VOCAL定量测量血流和血管分布较传统二维超声更准确、更敏感,并提供了一种实现准确判断和评估乳腺癌患者疗效的新方法。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: This study uses a three-dimensional energy Doppler technique combined with the Virtual Organ Computer-aided Analysis (VOCAL) method in order to determine the diagnostic threshold of blood flow index in breast tumors to provide a reference for evaluation and treatment options.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: We collected 322 solid lesions which had been operated. Each lesion met the definite pathological diagnosis; collected lesions included 262 cases of benign lesions and 60 cases of malignant lesions. All examinations were performed by using GE LOGIQ E9 with VOCAL software. Volume and four distinct vascular indices of gray mean (MG), power mean, ratio (R), and vascular flow index (VFI) were calculated by using the VOCAL software. Sampling and calculation were repeated three times and the mean value was calculated.
RESULTS: The average age and power of the malignant group were greater than those of the benign group, ie p < .01 which had significant differences. The gray mean of the malignant group was lower than that of the benign group, ie p > .05 which had no significant differences between benign and malignant groups. The ratio, vascular flow index and volume had significant differences, i.e. p < .01. The area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) were 0.864, 0.830, 0.800, 0.758, and 0.764 for age, power, ratio, vascular flow index, and volume, respectively. The research indicators were higher than 50% of the curve showing their diagnostic value. The cut-off points of age, power, ratio, vascular flow index, and volume were 37.5, 26.56, 0.031, 0.846, and 1.75, respectively. Their corresponding sensitivity were 93.3%, 75%, 81.7%, 68.3%, 63.3%, and the specificity were 68.7%, 81%, 70.2%, 75.6%, and 81.7%, respectively. Comparison of vascular indices combined with the Breast imaging reporting and data System (BI-RADS) score and simple BI-RADS method, the AUC of power + BI-RADS, ratio + BI-RADS, VFI + BI-RADS, and BI-RADS alone are 0.928, 0.903, 0.895, and 0.796, respectively, which were higher than 50% of the curve. Sensitivity was 81.7%, 80%, 88.3%, 86.7%, and specificity was 88.5%, 85.5%, 77.1%, 69.5%, respectively. The power + BI-RADS method has the highest AUC among these three methods.
CONCLUSIONS: Quantitative measurement of blood flow and blood vessel distribution in breast tumors by three-dimensional power Doppler ultrasound combined with the VOCAL method is more accurate and sensitive than the traditional two-dimensional ultrasound. And this method has potential promising applications in many current active research areas, such as the studies of random distribution of intratumoral blood vessels or the normalization of tumor blood vessels. Three-dimensional power Doppler ultrasound combined with the VOCAL method provides a new approach to achieving accurate judgments and the method evaluates the curative effect in breast cancer patients.
引用
- Wang H, Yan B, Yue L, et al. The Diagnostic Value of 3D Power Doppler Ultrasound Combined With VOCAL in the Vascular Distribution of Breast Masses. Acad Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31053481. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2019.02.023
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。