基于单层2D CT纹理分析对肾脏肿块的可靠性:观察者内和观察者间手动分割变异性对影像组学特征可重复性的影响
回顾性纳入30例透明细胞肾细胞癌患者,由三名不同经验放射科医生在不同场次对平扫和皮髓质期增强CT进行手动分割,提取744个纹理特征。观察者内良好至优秀可靠性率为84.4%-92.2%(平扫)和85.5%-93.1%(增强),观察者间为76.7%(平扫)和84.9%(增强)。结论认为基于单层2D CT纹理分析对肾脏肿块对分割变异性敏感,可能产生不可重复结果。
要点
- 观察者间可靠性低于观察者内,增强CT可靠性高于平扫。
- 灰度共生矩阵和一阶特征组可靠性较高。
- 滤波和变换图像特征可靠性优于原始图像。
核心结论
- 基于单层2D CT纹理分析对肾脏肿块对观察者内和观察者间手动分割变异性敏感,除非在工作流程中考虑可靠性分析,否则可能导致影像组学分析结果不可重复。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,从公共数据库纳入30例透明细胞肾细胞癌患者,三名不同经验放射科医生在不同场次对平扫CT和皮髓质期增强CT进行手动分割,提取744个纹理特征,使用组内相关系数进行可靠性分析。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 观察者内良好至优秀可靠性率:平扫CT为84.4%-92.2%,增强CT为85.5%-93.1%;观察者间良好至优秀可靠性率:平扫CT为76.7%,增强CT为84.9%;灰度共生矩阵和一阶特征组在平扫和增强CT上均显示较高良好至优秀可靠性率;滤波和变换图像较原始图像产生更多良好至优秀可靠性特征。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为基于单层2D CT纹理分析对肾脏肿块对分割变异性敏感,除非在工作流程中考虑可靠性分析,否则可能导致不可重复结果。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE. The objective of our study was to investigate the potential influence of intra- and interobserver manual segmentation variability on the reliability of single-slice-based 2D CT texture analysis of renal masses. MATERIALS AND METHODS. For this retrospective study, 30 patients with clear cell renal cell carcinoma were included from a public database. For intra- and interobserver analyses, three radiologists with varying degrees of experience segmented the tumors from unenhanced CT and corticomedullary phase contrast-enhanced CT (CECT) in different sessions. Each radiologist was blind to the image slices selected by other radiologists and him- or herself in the previous session. A total of 744 texture features were extracted from original, filtered, and transformed images. The intraclass correlation coefficient was used for reliability analysis. RESULTS. In the intraobserver analysis, the rates of features with good to excellent reliability were 84.4-92.2% for unenhanced CT and 85.5-93.1% for CECT. Considering the mean rates of unenhanced CT and CECT, having high experience resulted in better reliability rates in terms of the intraobserver analysis. In the interobserver analysis, the rates were 76.7% for unenhanced CT and 84.9% for CECT. The gray-level cooccurrence matrix and first-order feature groups yielded higher good to excellent reliability rates on both unenhanced CT and CECT. Filtered and transformed images resulted in more features with good to excellent reliability than the original images did on both unenhanced CT and CECT. CONCLUSION. Single-slice-based 2D CT texture analysis of renal masses is sensitive to intra- and interobserver manual segmentation variability. Therefore, it may lead to nonreproducible results in radiomic analysis unless a reliability analysis is considered in the workflow.
引用
- Kocak B, Durmaz ES, Kaya OK, et al. Reliability of Single-Slice-Based 2D CT Texture Analysis of Renal Masses: Influence of Intra- and Interobserver Manual Segmentation Variability on Radiomic Feature Reproducibility. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2019. PMID: 31063427. doi:10.2214/AJR.19.21212
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。