小肠克罗恩病活动性的磁共振小肠造影特征:临床实践环境下小肠活动性炎症的评分者间信度研究
该研究回顾性纳入7年间治疗前后行磁共振小肠造影的克罗恩病患者共80例次扫描,由非克罗恩病专长的腹部放射科医生对多种克罗恩病评分指数中的MRE特征进行评分。结果显示扩散受限、狭窄性疾病和整体严重程度为中等一致性,受累肠段长度为相当好一致性,而黏膜溃疡的存在无一致性。作者认为多数MRE特征可重复,但黏膜溃疡不可靠,可能需进一步研究后再作为治疗决策驱动因素。
要点
- 黏膜溃疡的存在评分者间无一致性(к=-0.07、-0.042),不宜单独作为治疗决策依据。
- 受累肠段长度一致性相当好(组内相关系数=0.67、0.61),但仅纳入一个克罗恩病评分指数。
- 扩散受限、狭窄性疾病、整体严重程度为中等一致性(к=0.43~0.59)。
核心结论
- 多数活动性克罗恩病的MRE特征由非克罗恩病专长的腹部放射科医生判读时具有可重复性。
- 黏膜溃疡的存在无评分者间一致性,可能需更多研究后再将其作为治疗决策的驱动因素。
- 研究提示非克罗恩病专长腹部放射科医生对黏膜溃疡的判读不可靠,是未来教育的潜在靶点。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,采用搜索查询在7年期间(2017年5月至2017年9月)识别治疗前后行MRE的克罗恩病患者。
- 研究人群共80例次扫描。
- 由放射科医生对同一肠段的多种克罗恩病评分指数包含的MRE特征进行评分。
- 名义分类变量和连续变量的一致性分别采用κ和组内相关系数评估。
关键影像表现/征象
- 治疗前和治疗后MRE中扩散受限均为中等一致性(к=0.43、0.48)。
- 治疗前和治疗后MRE中狭窄性疾病均为中等一致性(к=0.51、0.52)。
- 治疗前和治疗后MRE中整体严重程度均为中等一致性(к=0.49、0.59)。
- 治疗前和治疗后MRE中受累肠段长度均为相当好一致性(组内相关系数=0.67、0.61)。
- 治疗前和治疗后MRE中黏膜溃疡的存在均无一致性(к=-0.07、-0.042)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 扩散受限:治疗前к=0.43,治疗后к=0.48,为中等一致性。
- 狭窄性疾病:治疗前к=0.51,治疗后к=0.52,为中等一致性。
- 整体严重程度:治疗前к=0.49,治疗后к=0.59,为中等一致性。
- 受累肠段长度:治疗前组内相关系数=0.67,治疗后组内相关系数=0.61,为相当好一致性。
- 黏膜溃疡的存在:治疗前к=-0.07,治疗后к=-0.042,无一致性。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 非克罗恩病专长的腹部放射科医生判读扩散受限、狭窄性疾病、整体严重程度和受累肠段长度时具有中等至相当好的一致性。
- 黏膜溃疡的存在在非克罗恩病专长的腹部放射科医生间判读不可靠,作者认为可能需更多研究后再将其作为治疗决策的驱动因素。
- 作者指出研究应聚焦于弥合那些评分者间一致性差的特征。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study is to determine the interrater agreement in a clinical practice environment for the most commonly used magnetic resonance enterography (MRE) features of Crohn's disease (CD).
METHODS: CD patients with MRE's before and after treatment were retrospectively identified using search queries over a 7-year period (May 2017-September 2017). MRE features of CD comprising components of multiple CD scoring indices were scored by radiologists in the same segment of bowel. Agreement for nominal categorical and continuous variables was assessed using a κ and interclass correlation coefficients, respectively.
RESULTS: 80 scans comprised the study population. Moderate interrater agreement was seen in both the pre- and post-treatment MRE's for presence of diffusion restriction (к = 0.43, 0.48; pre- and post-treatment), stricturing disease (к = 0.51, 0.52), overall degree of severity (к = 0.49, 0.59). Substantial agreement was seen in pre- and post-treatment scans for length of involvement (interclass correlation coefficient = 0.67, 0.61). The presence of mucosal ulceration had no agreement (к = -0.07, -0.042).
CONCLUSION: Many MRE features of active CD comprising the major CD scoring indices are reproducible when interpreted by non-CD focused abdominal radiologists. However, the presence of mucosal ulcerations had no agreement and may need more investigation before including this feature as a driver in therapeutic decision making.
ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE: Demonstrates the unreliability of mucosal ulceration by non-CD focused abdominal radiologists, targeting a potential area for future education. Key Points The majority of MRE findings incorporated in to many CD scoring indices have fair to moderate inter-rater agreement even when read by non-MRE expert radiologists. Substantial agreement was seen in the length of involved bowel, but this feature is only incorporated in to one of the CD scoring indices. Presence of mucosal ulcerations had no interrater agreement in our study-a feature which is heavily weighted by several CD scoring indices. Research should be focused bridging those features which have poor interrater agreement.
引用
- Tsai R, Mintz A, Lin M, et al. Magnetic resonance enterography features of small bowel Crohn's disease activity: an inter-rater reliability study of small bowel active inflammation in clinical practice setting. Br J Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31141389. doi:10.1259/bjr.20180930
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。