一种用于检测和分级不同瓣盘运动异常情况下人工二尖瓣梗阻的新型多参数评分
本研究通过计算流体动力学模拟7种机械瓣构型与5种经胸多普勒超声速度曲线在4、5、6 L/min平均流量下的105个合成病例,发现单模态诊断在轻度和轻-重度狭窄中常无法预测血栓,据此提出一种多参数离散评分,其对狭窄百分比预测的准确率为90.5%,9.5%误差均为轻度狭窄(狭窄百分比=15%)被误判为轻-重度狭窄的假阳性,无假阴性。
要点
- 基于ASE指南的经胸多普勒超声单参数指标在相当数量病例中无法预测血栓,尤其轻度及轻-重度狭窄。
- 新型多参数离散评分预测狭窄百分比的准确率为90.5%,无假阴性,假阳性均为轻度狭窄(狭窄百分比=15%)误判为轻-重度狭窄。
- 可靠评估需同时考虑平均流量和经二尖瓣速度曲线。
核心结论
- 基于计算流体动力学模拟提出的新型多参数离散评分对狭窄百分比预测准确率为90.5%,无假阴性,9.5%误差为轻度狭窄(狭窄百分比=15%)被误判为轻-重度狭窄的假阳性。
研究设计与样本
- 计算流体动力学模拟研究,设计7种机械瓣构型(对应对称与非对称狭窄),采用5种来自真实经胸多普勒超声图像的病理经二尖瓣速度曲线,每种曲线缩放至平均流量4、5、6 L/min,共模拟105(7×5×3)个合成病例;经胸多普勒超声衍生指标按提取的ASE指南计算,参考标准为模拟设定的瓣膜构型与狭窄条件。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 经胸多普勒超声衍生指标按ASE指南计算;新型多参数离散评分预测狭窄百分比(POS)的准确率为90.5%,9.5%误差对应4例假阳性,均为轻度狭窄(POS=15%)被误分类为轻-重度狭窄,无假阴性。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为可靠评估必须同时考虑平均流量和经二尖瓣速度曲线,以提供正确诊断;基于该诊断算法构建的多参数离散评分可用于检测人工二尖瓣血栓。
局限性
- 单模态诊断在相当数量病例中无法预测血栓,涉及轻度和轻-重度狭窄病例。
- 9.5%的误差率对应4例假阳性,均为轻度狭窄(POS=15%)被误分类为轻-重度狭窄。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Prosthetic mechanical valves are the elective choice in mitral valve (MV) replacement, because of their reliability and easiness of implantation. However, these prostheses can suffer from complications, the major one being prosthetic mitral valve thrombosis (PMVT). In these cases, transthoracic doppler echocardiogram (TDE) is the standard diagnostic workup for diagnosis of valve malfunction. The American Society of Echocardiography (ASE) indicates the possible TDE-derived indexes, which can help in identifying insurgence of MV replacement complications. Unfortunately, in some cases, it is not possible to detect PMVT based on these criteria. In these cases, we speak of Doppler silent thrombosis and only more accurate and invasive analyses, such as fluoroscopy, allow for a correct diagnosis. In this work, computational fluid dynamic models were implemented to simulate valve fluid dynamics in different clinical scenarios in order to improve the reliability of PMVT diagnosis based on TDE. In detail, seven mechanical valve configurations, associated to different potential thrombotic conditions (symmetric and asymmetric stenosis), were designed and tested using five pathologic transmitral velocity profile, extracted from real TDE images; to obtain the flow rate profiles, each TDE velocity profile was scaled to yield a mean flow rate (MFR) of 4, 5 and 6 L/min, respectively. As a result, 105 (7 × 5 × 3) synthetic cases, accounting for different velocity profiles, MFRs and valve configurations, were simulated. TDE-derived indexes were calculated according to the ASE guidelines that were extracted. Advanced statistical methods were applied to propose a new diagnostic algorithm for detecting PMVT. Our results showed that there isn't any significant difference between symmetric and asymmetric stenosis, probe location and flow rate waveform and confirmed that the single modality diagnostic is not able to predict thrombosis in a relevant number of cases, referable to mild and mild-severe stenosis cases. To overcome the problem, a novel multi-parametric discrete score based on the designed diagnostic algorithm was attained and tested; the percentage of stenosis (POS) was predicted with an accuracy rate of 90.5%. Even more interestingly, the error rate of 9.5% is related to four false positive cases corresponding to mild stenosis (POS = 15%) which were erroneously classified as mild-severe stenosis. No false negatives were obtained. Our results suggest that a reliable estimation must take into account the mean flow rate as well as the transmitral velocity profile in order to provide a correct diagnosis.
引用
- Meskin M, Dimasi A, Votta E, et al. A Novel Multiparametric Score for the Detection and Grading of Prosthetic Mitral Valve Obstruction in Cases With Different Disc Motion Abnormalities. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2019. PMID: 31060859. doi:10.1016/j.ultrasmedbio.2019.03.011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。